| 前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ |
| 作成者 |
メッセージ |
stevemark
 登録日: 2011年4月29日 投稿: 5509 所在地: Switzerland
|
 投稿日時: 火 1月 16, 2024 9:29 pm 件名: TEST Zeiss CY 3.3-4.5/28-85mm vs Vivitar S1 28-90mm & ot |
|
 投稿日時: 火 1月 16, 2024 9:29 pm 件名: TEST Zeiss CY 3.3-4.5/28-85mm vs Vivitar S1 28-90mm & ot |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
Recently I got a nice Zeiss Vario-Sonnar 3.3-4/28-85mm. This lens always has sparked my curiosity, especially since the Zeiss CY Vario-Sonnars 3.5/70-210mm and CY 4/80-200mm are the sharpest zooms of their time.
In this thread I will publish some information comparing the Zeiss with several other lenses at different focal lengths. Those comparisons will include the peers from Canon / Minolta / Nikon / Yashica, but also less common and not so well known lenses as well - for refence - well known primes.
To start with I did a comparison at f=50mm at dawn. The point light sources will allow to judge coma. Here are some 100% crops from corners of 24 MP FF JPGs from the A7II:
1) Minolta MD-III 2/50mm
2) Panagor PMC Auto Zoom 3.5/35-100mm
3) Vivitar Series 1 VMC Macro Focusing 2.8-3.5/28-90mm (varifocal lens!)
4) Carl Zeiss Vario-Sonnar 3.3-4/28-85mm
ATTENTION: MY BROWSER (FIREFOX) IS MESSING WITH THE UPLOADED FILES, SHOWING THEM EITHER TOO SMALL OR ENLARGED TO SCREEN SIZE, CAUSING PRONPOUNCED LOSS OF DETAIL IN EITHER CASE. PLEASE DOWNLOAD AND WATCH AT 100% IN A PROPER PROGRAM SUCH AS PHOTOSHOP!
First the overview:
100% crops from the corner:
100% crops from near the border:
I'm a bit surprised that the Zeiss, quite an expensive lens in its days (and realtively modern) doesn't really outperform the two other zoom/varifocal lenses (let alone the cheapo Minolta prime).
More information will follow. _________________ www.artaphot.ch
最終編集: stevemark、火 1月 16, 2024 10:05 pm、計 1 回 |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
kiddo
 登録日: 2018年6月29日 投稿: 1630
|
 投稿日時: 火 1月 16, 2024 9:46 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 火 1月 16, 2024 9:46 pm 件名: |
|
|
kiddo wrote:
wow, not really what i´ve expected from zeiss, i was going to tell you to include the affordable and easy available minolta 35-70mm zoom (i know it´s not a 28mm)
of course this is a torture test for most of these lenses, probably in daylight shooting, zeiss might show some more details
at 5.6 minolta has more details than any other lens at f11, as expected from such a good prime |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
stevemark
 登録日: 2011年4月29日 投稿: 5509 所在地: Switzerland
|
 投稿日時: 火 1月 16, 2024 10:14 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 火 1月 16, 2024 10:14 pm 件名: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| kiddo 氏の書き込み: |
wow, not really what i´ve expected from zeiss, i was going to tell you to include the affordable and easy available minolta 35-70mm zoom (i know it´s not a 28mm)
of course this is a torture test for most of these lenses, probably in daylight shooting, zeiss might show some more details
at 5.6 minolta has more details than any other lens at f11, as expected from such a good prime |
I will certainly publish several tests under different light conditions.
I've been reading several other CY 28-85mm reviews in the net, and several of them confirm that the Zeiss isn't perfectly sharp in the corners, not even stopped stopped down. So probably not an issue with my sample, but real world performance. See e. g. here: https://www.addicted2light.com/2016/11/24/review-contax-vario-sonnar-28-85-mm-f3-3-4/?v=1ee0bf89c5d1
I remember back in the days (mid-end 1990s) that there were complains about "missing" performance of the Minolta AF 2.8/28-70mm lens. Fast midrange zooms were notoriously difficult to compute. Remember Nikons midrange professional zoom was 2.8/35-70mm in the early 1990s (Zeiss 28-85 came out in 1988).
It will be interesting to see how the "Big Five" 28-85mm lenses from around 1985-1990 compare (Canon FD, Minolta MD/AF, Nikon AiS/AF, Yashica ML, Zeiss CY). Obviously 35-70mm was much much easier to compute back then!
I guess the Zeiss was more desiged as a reportage lens than a landscape zoom.
S
EDIT Zeiss MTF data do confirm the rather low border/corner performance:
https://www.zeiss.ch/content/dam/consumer-products/downloads/historical-products/photography/contax-yashica/de/datasheet-zeiss-vario-sonnar-33402885-de.pdf _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
Doc Sharptail
 登録日: 2020年11月23日 投稿: 1504 所在地: Winnipeg Canada
|
 投稿日時: 水 1月 17, 2024 1:20 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 水 1月 17, 2024 1:20 am 件名: |
|
|
Doc Sharptail wrote:
| stevemark 氏の書き込み: |
I guess the Zeiss was more designed as a reportage lens than a landscape zoom. S |
I wonder how many lenses were planned/designed in this manner.
There's another I know of- the old Nikkor "H" 50mm f2, and possibly the old Nikkor 80-200 f4.5 N.
-D.S. _________________
D-810, F2, FTN, FT-3 in Black
35mm f2 O.C. nikkor
50 f2 H nikkor, 50 f2 H.C. nikkor, 50 f 1.4 AI-s, 135 f3.5 Q,
50 f2 K nikkor 2x, 28-85mm f3.5-4.5 A/I-s, 35-105 3.5-4.5 A/I-s, 200mm f4 Micro A/I, partial list.
"Ain't no half-way" -S.R.V.
"Oh Yeah... Alright" -Paul Simon |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
caspert79
 登録日: 2010年10月31日 投稿: 3911 所在地: The Netherlands
|
 投稿日時: 水 1月 17, 2024 9:01 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 水 1月 17, 2024 9:01 am 件名: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
The Panagor does surprisingly well. How good is it at other focal lengths? |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
Oldhand
 登録日: 2013年4月1日 投稿: 6016 所在地: Mid North Coast NSW - Australia
|
 投稿日時: 水 1月 17, 2024 10:36 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 水 1月 17, 2024 10:36 am 件名: |
|
|
Oldhand wrote:
| Doc Sharptail 氏の書き込み: |
| stevemark 氏の書き込み: |
I guess the Zeiss was more designed as a reportage lens than a landscape zoom. S |
I wonder how many lenses were planned/designed in this manner.
There's another I know of- the old Nikkor "H" 50mm f2, and possibly the old Nikkor 80-200 f4.5 N.
-D.S. |
Certainly the Vivitar 28-90 became a favourite of street photography.
I think it was referred to as the stovepipe.
Tom |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
lumens pixel
 登録日: 2019年2月27日 投稿: 1128
Expire: 2021-06-25
|
 投稿日時: 水 1月 17, 2024 12:16 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 水 1月 17, 2024 12:16 pm 件名: |
|
|
lumens pixel wrote:
Very interesting. Of course the Minolta 50 is impressive. At such focal lenght the Panagor is surprising. Who was the manufacturer? _________________ Lumens Pixel
-------------
Minolta SR mount: 16 2,8; Sigma SuperWide 24 2,8; 28 2,5; 28 2,8; 28 3,5; 35 2,8; 45 2,0; 50 1,4; 50 1,7; 50 2,0; 58 1,4; 85 2,0; 100 2,5; 100 4 Macro; 135 3,5; 135 2,8; 200 4; RF 250 5,6; 24-35 3,5; 35-70 3,5; 75-150 4; 70-210 4
Canon FD mount: Tokina RMC 17 3,5; 28 2,8; 35 2,8; 50 1,8; 50 3,5 Macro; 55 1,2; 135 3,5; 135 2,5; 200 4,0; 300 5,6; 28-55 3,5 4,5; Tokina SZ-X SD 270; 70-150 4,5; 70-210 f4; 80-200 4L; Tokina SZ-X 845
Tamron Adaptall: 28-80 3,5-4,2 (27A); 70-210 3,8-4 (46A); 60-300 (23A); 90 2,5 (52B); 35-135 3,5-4,5 (40A)
Tamron SP: 20-40 2,7-3,5 (266D) |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
stevemark
 登録日: 2011年4月29日 投稿: 5509 所在地: Switzerland
|
 投稿日時: 水 1月 17, 2024 6:22 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 水 1月 17, 2024 6:22 pm 件名: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| caspert79 氏の書き込み: |
| The Panagor does surprisingly well. How good is it at other focal lengths? |
I was very surprised too since my first shots with the Panagor had indicated a pretty bad performance. I haven't tested other focal lengths yet, since the weather is a bit disappointing lately
All these results are preliminary (although carefully made as ususal with tripod, self timer and electronic 1st shutter to avoid any movenemts).
| Oldhand 氏の書き込み: |
Certainly the Vivitar 28-90 became a favourite of street photography.
Tom |
Interesting! Why? I always though that street photographers would prefer fixed focal lengths? Occasionally I do street photography, and usually I prefer either a 20mm (going really close) or a 2.8/200mm APO (to get nice separation from the background).
| lumens pixel 氏の書き込み: |
| Very interesting. Of course the Minolta 50 is impressive. At such focal lenght the Panagor is surprising. Who was the manufacturer? |
I have no idea. Olypedia has a data sheet, but no information on the manufacturer:
https://olypedia.de/images/8/83/Panagor_PMC_Auto_Zoom_35-100_3.5.jpg
Jaca Corp. (Tokyo) seems to have been the owner of both the Elicar and Panagor trademarks. In Switzerland the Panagor lenses were branded as Admiral GMC, "GMC" meaning "Gujer, Meuli & Co". Gujer, Meuli & Co still exists (albeit under a new name), and still is selling photo products.
Several websites claim Kino Precision and Komine as manufacturers of some the Panagor lenses. That may well be true for the Panagor 3.5/35-100mm as it looks and feels pretty well-made (and in fact quite similar to the Vivitar S1 28-90mm*). The same can be said about my Admiral (Panagor) 2.8/90mm Macro and the two Admiral (Panagor) tele lenses 3.5/200mm and 5.6/300mm I own. Compared to contemporary Canon / Minolta /Nikon lenses, all these lenses may be slightly inferior, but certainly not much.
S
* Engravings are made very nicely on both the Panagor 35-100mm as well as the Vivitar S1 28-90mm; the letters used are not identical though. That doesn't exclude Komine as a manufacturer of both lenses since the Vivitar-letters are specific to Vivitar (independently of the manufacturer). _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
cbass
 登録日: 2019年7月27日 投稿: 457
|
 投稿日時: 木 1月 18, 2024 4:47 am 件名: Re: TEST Zeiss CY 3.3-4.5/28-85mm vs Vivitar S1 28-90mm & |
|
 投稿日時: 木 1月 18, 2024 4:47 am 件名: Re: TEST Zeiss CY 3.3-4.5/28-85mm vs Vivitar S1 28-90mm & |
|
|
cbass wrote:
| stevemark 氏の書き込み: |
I'm a bit surprised that the Zeiss, quite an expensive lens in its days (and realtively modern) doesn't really outperform the two other zoom/varifocal lenses (let alone the cheapo Minolta prime).
More information will follow. |
This is in agreement with the official MTF chart where the lens performance drops off aggressively at 15-17mm depending on focal length. 28mm being a wild a crazy ride. However, before 15mm the performance is exceptional.
https://www.zeiss.com/content/dam/consumer-products/downloads/historical-products/photography/contax-yashica/en/datasheet-zeiss-vario-sonnar-33402885-en.pdf |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
stevemark
 登録日: 2011年4月29日 投稿: 5509 所在地: Switzerland
|
 投稿日時: 木 1月 18, 2024 6:53 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 木 1月 18, 2024 6:53 pm 件名: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| caspert79 氏の書き込み: |
| The Panagor does surprisingly well. How good is it at other focal lengths? |
Well, after playing a bit with the Panagor today I have to say: Not so good!
Weather conditions were not favourable for tests (quickly changing light - sun, rain, mist, snow ...), but the Panagor 3.5/35-100mm definitely is pretty weak both at f=35mm as well as at f=100mm!
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
caspert79
 登録日: 2010年10月31日 投稿: 3911 所在地: The Netherlands
|
 投稿日時: 木 1月 18, 2024 7:26 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 木 1月 18, 2024 7:26 pm 件名: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| stevemark 氏の書き込み: |
| caspert79 氏の書き込み: |
| The Panagor does surprisingly well. How good is it at other focal lengths? |
Well, after playing a bit with the Panagor today I have to say: Not so good!
Weather conditions were not favourable for tests (quickly changing light - sun, rain, mist, snow ...), but the Panagor 3.5/35-100mm definitely is pretty weak both at f=35mm as well as at f=100mm!
S |
Bummer, thanks for testing 👠|
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
D1N0
 登録日: 2012年8月7日 投稿: 2726
|
 投稿日時: 金 1月 19, 2024 2:49 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 1月 19, 2024 2:49 pm 件名: |
|
|
D1N0 wrote:
Weak means those are the focal length's where it shows character _________________ pentaxian |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
cbass
 登録日: 2019年7月27日 投稿: 457
|
 投稿日時: 土 1月 20, 2024 3:16 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 土 1月 20, 2024 3:16 pm 件名: |
|
|
cbass wrote:
| D1N0 氏の書き込み: |
| Weak means those are the focal length's where it shows character |
One man’s character is another man’s aberrations. Todays clinical lens is tomorrows character lens. |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
stevemark
 登録日: 2011年4月29日 投稿: 5509 所在地: Switzerland
|
 投稿日時: 土 1月 20, 2024 7:07 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 土 1月 20, 2024 7:07 pm 件名: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
Minolta MD 3.5-4.5/28-85mm vs Panagor PMC 3.5/35-100mm Zeiss CY 3.3-4/28-85mm vs @ 85mm.
100% crops from the corners JPGs from 24 MP FF Soiny A7II:
CLICK TWICE TO GET THE ORIGINAL IMAGE - IT'S BEST TO DOWNLOAD AND LOOK AT IT IN A DEDICATED PRPOGRAM SUCH AS PHOTOSHOP (MANY BROWSERS TEND TO RESIZE THE IMAGE TO SCREEN SIZE)
Both the Minolta as well as the Zeiss are pretty good at their long end; actually there's not much difference between images taken wide open and at f9. The Panagor - which has a completely different positive leading optical layout - is pretty soft wide open, and CAs are harsh and well visible. Stopped down to f11 the resolution is very good too, but CAs still are bit strong.
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
|
|
|
このフォーラムでは新しいトピックを投稿できません このフォーラムではトピックに返信できません このフォーラムでは自分の投稿を編集できません このフォーラムでは自分の投稿を削除できません このフォーラムでは投票に参加できません
|