MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

Nex-3 Auto ISO difficulty
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

hi guys,
is your Nex-3 camera handling Auto ISO well, or poorly?
In my camera, it seems to not work as it should. If I shoot in Time priority, and stop down the lens,
the photos get darker, while the Auto ISO does not apply the needed compensation.
I'd like to know your experiences with that. Am I doing anything wrongly?


Reply

I think it's supposed to go up to 1600, then if it's too dark, photos will be dark. You're in time priority so you set the time and I assume you're using a manual lens with manual aperture, so the only parameter left to the camera is ISO. And it will very quickly run out of options, minimum is 200, maximum is 1600, that's a span of only 3 stops.

Personally I almost always use A mode and manual ISO.


Reply

With a manual lens the NEX-3 does not know the focal length and cannot control the aperture.
Thus auto ISO does not make much sense. The cam goes down to 1/30s before adjusting ISO settings.

I have never used auto ISO with a manual lens because of that.


Reply

Auto ISO is handled not so good in nex system since you cannot choose the range of ISO, with mf I use the auto setting only in some cases, otherwise I pick the ISO and I shot in Time priority


Reply

OK, thanks guys, Carsten explained me the situation.


Reply

I've never used it. I have found that I never need to use higher than 200 because I use a tripod a lot. I hate noise so I find only 200 and 400 to be usable, 800 only at a pinch.

I'm interested to know how you're using yours, I'm always looking to pick up tips. Smile


Reply

Normally with my Canon when I take pictures around (i.e. when I am not making an accurate photo job) I set the camera
to Auto ISO with the limiter on 1600 and the shooting mode to Time Priority in order to be sure to take photos that are not shaken.
Then I adjust the aperture at will/need, relying on AutoISO for compensation.
This workflow is not possible with Nex-3 and manual lenses apparently. Not a big deal, but it would have been nice to have.


Reply

I've had the same problem and found that its only any good with the kit lens.


Reply

You guys are lucky in that you can even use Auto ISO. Ian has an old Canon like me, and I can tell by his response that he's run into the same issues I have. With my XS/1000D, ISO 200 is acceptable, but anything above that is too noisy for me. There is considerable detail loss at ISO 400. ISO 800 is good only for emergencies. And ISO 1600, which is as high as my XS gets, is, well it's there, and that's about all I can say about it. I have mine permanently set to ISO 100. And, like Ian, I use a tripod or monopod a lot, but even then, not as much as I should.

Actually, I don't trust Auto ISO, to be completely honest. When I bought my XS, the default ISO setting was Auto, so the first few times I used the camera, this was what the ISO was set to. And I noticed when reviewing the photos how some of them were very noisy and others weren't. It was then that I noticed the ISO setting. Recently I bought a P&S Nikon digital -- a model LC28, which features a whopping 20 megapixels in a camera that costs new about 100 bucks (US). But it's a beginner's camera with Auto ISO only, and I have found that it takes great pictures only in bright sun conditions, where its Auto function is allowing ISO 100. Otherwise the LC28's images range from "just OK" to "awful." Rolling Eyes If somebody is buying one of these Nikon LC28s as an upgrade to their phone's camera, then buying it makes sense. But just barely.

You know, even if I owned a camera that handled higher ISO numbers with very little detectable noise, honestly I still don't know if I would trust it to give me what I want if it controls ISO and I don't.


Reply

I have never ever used auto ISO.
Until I got my Fuji X-E1, that is. So, until last week. Wink

Seriously, since you do not see any noise in the images of the X-E1 at ISO1600 at all, you can easily use auto ISO.

And still, I normally don't. Wink


Reply

I never use Auto ISO on my NEX5, I like to keep the ISO as low as I can, so I set the ISO as low as I think I can get away with either hand held or usually on the tripod, set the camera on Shutter Priority, set the aperture on the lens, and then judge the exposure in live view. If it's hand held I flick though ap's and speeds first, then ISO's, until I think I can hold it steady. If it's on the tripod then ISO is as low as I can go and the aperture is the important setting, the speed is largely unimportant. I don't even know if Auto ISO works with this kind of workflow?


Reply

I'm surprised at the comments about the 1000D's noise to be honest. It should be clean to iso 800...are you shooting in jpg? I only ever used the raw output when I had one.

My Canon 6D has a nice auto iso implementation. I shoot in av mode and specify the minimum acceptable shutter speed. I also have an Olympus pen e-pm1 which uses the lens focal length x multiplier to work out the minimum shutter speed before bumping up the iso (which is annoying as the stabilisation is superb).

I always manually specified the iso with my nex as far as I can remember.


Reply

Right, in A mode it goes to 1/30th before upping the ISO and certainly it would be better if one could choose the shortest shutter speed before it starts upping the ISO ( or tell the camera the focal lengths used and it would choose min. shutter speed accordingly )

The shortest shutter speed before the camera ups the ISO being 'fixed' I find 1/30th sec. ideal, it is the shortest I can handhold with most lenses I use and wouldn't want it to be different. Or in other words certainly I find Auto ISO very useful also as it is and I am surprised that most of you don't.

I pretty much always use Auto ISO on my NEX5N, mostly in A mode. If I use a long lens or for other reasons need a faster shutter speed I change to S mode, again with auto ISO ( all that with manual lenses setting aperture on the lens. )

anyway Orio's camera also should up the ISO in S mode and why it doesn't do it has not been clarified.


最終編集: kuuan、日 10月 13, 2013 10:30 am、計 1 回


Reply

kuuan 氏の書き込み:

anyway, why Orio's camera would not up the ISO in S mode has not been explained, I only can think of his camera being faulty.


They say Auto ISO works only when the camera recognizes a lens via the electronic contacts.


Reply

Orio 氏の書き込み:
kuuan 氏の書き込み:

anyway, why Orio's camera would not up the ISO in S mode has not been explained, I only can think of his camera being faulty.


They say Auto ISO works only when the camera recognizes a lens via the electronic contacts.


hm..who says so? Auto ISO definitely works very well at least on my NEX5N, and as I understand also Carstens says it works, just he doesn't deem it to be useful because in A mode it goes down to 1/30 sec. before it starts upping the ISO which he must find to be too short.
btw. S mode with Auto ISO with a lens without electrical contacts, at least on my NEX and I am pretty sure that this is true for any NEX , works like what Pentax and now also Ricoh GR calls TAv mode, that is M mode + auto ISO + exposure compensation: aperture is chosen on lens, shutter speed on camera, Auto ISO will change ISO to expose correctly and that incl. exposure compensation ( if + exp. comp. ISO goes up, - exp. comp. ISO goes down )


Reply

auto ISO in S mode certainly should work, also on NEX3:
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/3096512#forum-post-39834955
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/3108510


最終編集: kuuan、日 10月 13, 2013 4:31 pm、計 1 回


Reply

Here's the deal with Auto ISO on NEX-3 and 5. It does not work in M-mode, but it does work in S mode. Auto ISO is limited to ISO 1600 and changing that limit is not possible. So the workflow that Orio wants is possible in S mode. In fact, that's exactly the workflow that I use with manual lenses when it gets darker. It's not the best implementation of Auto ISO, but it's usable.


Reply

fermy 氏の書き込み:
Here's the deal with Auto ISO on NEX-3 and 5. It does not work in M-mode, but it does work in S mode. Auto ISO is limited to ISO 1600 and changing that limit is not possible. So the workflow that Orio wants is possible in S mode. In fact, that's exactly the workflow that I use with manual lenses when it gets darker. It's not the best implementation of Auto ISO, but it's usable.


right

kind of irritating that the OP either denies or ignores our efforts to help him


Reply

Thanks fermy and kuuan! The auto ISO is very useful in light changing situation. I should have learn how to use the Auto ISO earlier right after I bought my 5N. Embarassed


Reply

calvin83 氏の書き込み:
Thanks fermy and kuuan! The auto ISO is very useful in light changing situation. I should have learn how to use the Auto ISO earlier right after I bought my 5N. Embarassed


most welcome calvin Smile

as pointed out S mode + auto ISO with a lens with aperture ring equals Pentax's TAv mode which imo is something any modern 'serious' camera should offer.

however I prefer A mode with much sunlight and A mode + auto ISO at low light in case I don't need faster shutter than 1/30th. S mode with plenty light with ISO already at it's lowest may lead to overexposure in case one forgets to manually shorten shutter speed according to aperture chosen ( resp. to higher ISO than necessary if shutter chosen is too short ). Of course one will notice overexposure in EVF or LCD in time to correct, but 'in the field' I usually prefer being able to fully rely on auto exposure instead of the delay of having to adjust manually

btw. Ricoh GXR M with adapted lenses works the same


Reply

kuuan 氏の書き込み:
calvin83 氏の書き込み:
Thanks fermy and kuuan! The auto ISO is very useful in light changing situation. I should have learn how to use the Auto ISO earlier right after I bought my 5N. Embarassed


most welcome calvin Smile

as pointed out S mode + auto ISO with a lens with aperture ring equals Pentax's TAv mode which imo is something any modern 'serious' camera should offer.

however I prefer A mode with much sunlight and A mode + auto ISO at low light in case I don't need faster shutter than 1/30th. S mode + auto ISO with plenty light, if ISO already is at it's lowest ( and commonly if one chooses a fast aperture ), will lead to overexposure in case one forgets to manually shorten shutter speed accordingly. ( of course one will notice in EVF or LCD in time, but 'in the field' I prefer being able to fully rely on auto exposure instead of the delay of having to adjust manually )

These tips will be helpful for those who use manual lens on their NEX.

I tried the auto ISO today in S mode. It is useful for maintaining safe shutter speed. A mode still is my first choice but I do have more combo to use.


Reply

right!

A mode + auto ISO is most useful for most situations!

S mode + auto ISO only is indicated, of course, if one wants a certain shutter speed ( and you want the camera to automatically expose correctly, choosing the needed ISO according to the aperture set on the lens ) and if one 'needs' a faster shutter speed ( or try for a shorter, to 'save' ISO, if you can handhold it ) than the 1/30th sec. A mode + auto ISO chooses for any ISO higher than base ISO


最終編集: kuuan、火 10月 15, 2013 11:35 am、計 1 回


Reply

I never had problem with NEX-3, NEX-C3 and NEX-5N in time priority mode

But ultra fast shutter speeds (~1/2000s and more) did produce underexposure problems at least with my NEX-5N and manual wide angles and lenses with short flange back, no matter if ISO was set manually or auto. That does only occur with manual lenses for some reason, not with dedicated E-Mount lenses. It caused uneven- and underexposure. I had never testet that with NEX-3 and C3 but maybe it has something to do with your problem? That has something to do with the distance between shutter and sensor and their synchronisation and is not a unique-to-NEX problem - other cameras have the same little issue.
Sample





NEX-3 and NEX-5 are fully usable to ISO1600
and NEX-5N, C3 and later are fully usable up to 3200 imho

Sample: NEX-C3, speed priority mode, ISO1250 (auto), 1/2000s - works very well imho and noise does not offend me

Crop:



Crop:



How offending noise is highly depends on your monitor in my experience. If you print them even in A3 or A2 size noise is much harder to find than on my Samsung 24" monitor. On my 24" Benq I had befor noise looked much worse.


Reply

ForenSeil 氏の書き込み:
I never had problem with NEX-3, NEX-C3 and NEX-5N in time priority mode

[b]But ultra fast shutter speeds (~1/2000s and more) did produce underexposure problems at least with my NEX-5N and manual wide angles and lenses with short flange back, no matter if ISO was set manually or auto. ..........


I believe your findings though I had not noticed myself. I believe it because I had noticed that, when using non native lenses, at very bright sun my Pentax dSLR often underexposed, and the Ricoh GXR M though less does it too. To me it seems that the NEX does the best job of the 3, but nevertheless it may underexpose whenever there is very strong sunlight.

ForenSeil 氏の書き込み:

and NEX-5N, C3 and later are fully usable up to 3200 imho


fully agree

earlier in this thread I had made a mistake, please note:
    in A mode with auto ISO the camera usually will go as slow as 1/60th sec. of shutter speed before it starts upping the ISO from base ISO
    NOT to 1/30sec. as I had written earlier!