MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

CCD vs CMOS
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

this is gonna be fun! just found this on Gizmodo

http://gizmodo.com/these-neat-animations-show-how-cmos-and-ccd-sensors-wor-1702771058?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+gizmodo%2Ffull+%28Gizmodo%29

so, is it that 'a sensor is a sensor is a sensor' or not? i know two things: one is that interpreting data depends in large part on the interpreter; and two, i know what i see when i see it! so for me, people can say what they want and be as dismissive and condescending as is their wont, but photography remains a subjective art that is based entirely on how each individual's eye processes a photo. my eye processes a difference in images produced by these two sensors. maybe this is why...


Reply

I am totally with you. The most important thing is what our brain is doing with the information our eyes deliver to it. It is totally irrelevant how this information is coming to our eyes. The real magic lies in our brain. That is why this subject is as subjective as it is. Same is true for audio. That's the main reason why all the discussions of whether this or that is better are so difficult because what is better for your brain may not be better for mine. However, discussions about audio are far more easier as there you can perform blind testing. That is obviously not possible for visual impressions. The only thing which is possible is to measure technically any results of any method. However, that does not change anything of the previous statement, because what is technically better does not mean that an individual brain will judge it likewise. I am sometimes very amused about some discussions about this topic as this psychological phenomena is most of the time totally ignored. The only thing what you can expect from technical equipment is, that it delivers technically measurable good results. The rest is simple imagination out of our brain, if of course the eyes or ears are still working as a minimum requirement. Wink


Reply

ccd or cmos is just one tiny part of a much larger equation. Lots of other factors to consider so it's a moot point.


Reply

thomas thank you for such a relevant and thoughful comment, for as we can see both are hard to come by! i bet you agree that the vastly different way these sensors capture light cannot help but have an effect on the final result. its almost like how different films interact with light to effect the resulting image. ive always felt that was a common sense interpretation, but seeing it visually played out somehow adds more 'sense' to the common!


Reply

I agree with Ian. I also agree the difference can be seen.

However, the display & brain interpretation may be the biggest factor -- especially solid state displays which can only radiate 3 specific wavelengths of light, which combine to fool the eye & brain into thinking there's a spectrum of colors, when in fact there are only 3 wavelengths.

As with Audio, Visual reproduction is very very crude.

You know that some animals can see individual video frames? Increase the frame rate, however, the animal will see motion of video.


Reply

rbelyell 氏の書き込み:
i bet you agree that the vastly different way these sensors capture light cannot help but have an effect on the final result. its almost like how different films interact with light to effect the resulting image.


Exactly. But it's more or less nice to know for the interested people HOW the result is generated. Actually I don't care. The result must be measurable above a certain limit. The rest is "taste" as we also may call it; or "imagination" out of several basic (individual learned) settings in our brain, what the more precise term would be.
Reminds me also on the endless discussions whether this or that film generates the better result, besides of measurable facts like size of the grain or so. As soon as we add the magic word "art" to the discussion objectivity is gone anyway. Wink


Reply

I always like the CCD. My D200 had a look that the D300 could not match. When I bought the M9 the CCD was a deciding factor and yes the images from that were awesome. When I got the D800E for long lenses, I was able to make a comparison to the M9 and I could not tell any difference. I put them on the forums and no one else could tell the difference. Yes on older cameras it does matter but I think on later cameras, it does not make much difference at all.
Pete


Reply

well i think it doesnt matter much now because no new cameras use ccd. but comparing my ccd cams, i find i cannot duplicate that look that i like with the new cameras, even the fabulous rx1. they have their good points, but in the same way you cant put your finger on exactly why certain lenses render with what we refer to as 'character', so too imo do ccd sensors. i think these videos demonstrate in a way everyone can understand that ccd handles light very differently than cmos. imo, since many do 'see' a difference, it seems logical to me that if it handles light differently it will render differently.


Reply

visualopsins 氏の書き込み:
I agree with Ian. I also agree the difference can be seen.

However, the display & brain interpretation may be the biggest factor -- especially solid state displays which can only radiate 3 specific wavelengths of light, which combine to fool the eye & brain into thinking there's a spectrum of colors, when in fact there are only 3 wavelengths.

As with Audio, Visual reproduction is very very crude.

You know that some animals can see individual video frames? Increase the frame rate, however, the animal will see motion of video.


Pigeons see at a much faster frame rate than we do.

I still say sensor type is just one of very many factors and isn't all that significant to the end result as many other factors have far more influence.


Reply

youve said it once already--how many more times do you need to say the same thing. perhaps if you scream it really loudly out your window we would all finally understand your thoughts on the matter.


Reply

rbelyell 氏の書き込み:
youve said it once already--how many more times do you need to say the same thing. perhaps if you scream it really loudly out your window we would all finally understand your thoughts on the matter.


Excuse me, but you really need to learn some manners and stop being so rude.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 氏の書き込み:
visualopsins 氏の書き込み:
I agree with Ian. I also agree the difference can be seen.

However, the display & brain interpretation may be the biggest factor -- especially solid state displays which can only radiate 3 specific wavelengths of light, which combine to fool the eye & brain into thinking there's a spectrum of colors, when in fact there are only 3 wavelengths.

As with Audio, Visual reproduction is very very crude.

You know that some animals can see individual video frames? Increase the frame rate, however, the animal will see motion of video.


Pigeons see at a much faster frame rate than we do.

I still say sensor type is just one of very many factors and isn't all that significant to the end result as many other factors have far more influence.


Exactly -- so pidgeons may see only individual frames at 30fps -- cannot see video until frame rate is increased.

I agree the rendering part of the equation has such a huge effect that little if any differences between sensors could possibly be seen. There is only a slight difference in RGB triplet derivation. The differences between display and print are huge in comparison; even the differences in print mediums is huge compared to sensor difference!


Reply

One factor is RAW vs JPEG. I almost always shoot RAW, with all of my digicams, and I have noticed that the amount of processing each camera does to the RAW data if you shoot in JPEG mode varies quite a bit. For instance, my Pentax Q7 in JPEG mode applies quite a lot of processing, whereas my SONY a850 appears to do very little, but is still definitely doing some sharpening. Therefore, if one shoots JPEG rather than RAW, you don't ever get to see the sensor's output, but rather a processed version and this processing will certainly be a mitigating factor in any CCD vs CMOS or similar discussion.

I always do some PP to my images, often I do quite extensive PP, and that really means the 'look' of the sensor is overridden by the 'look' I chose to give the images. I actually shoot my images with the PP I will subsequently do to them in mind.

What I have often wondered, how much difference is there between conventional Bayer type sensors and the Foveon and X-Trans types, but those sensors have sadly only appeared in cameras that don't appeal to me much such as the Fuji S3 and S5 (although the newer X series does appeal) and the Sigma DP and SD series.

That said, with the way I apply PP, it's probably largely irrelevant what sensor type I happen to be using; however I still fancy trying out one of the Fuji X series cameras one day.


Reply

visualopsins 氏の書き込み:
...especially solid state displays which can only radiate 3 specific wavelengths of light, which combine to fool the eye & brain into thinking there's a spectrum of colors, when in fact there are only 3 wavelengths...

Your eyes only contain 3 types of optical sensors (cells known as cones) used for determining colour. Spectral sensitivity for the cones do overlap but the peak wavelengths for each type are quite distinct (The other structures called rods are used in low light situations and have no colour sensitivity).
The three wavelengths chosen for optical displays are selected specifically because of how they interact with the cones so that the system can stimulate cones in the same way that any natural light would. So it's not surprising that the displays can match real world colours.

Part of the reason for the subjectivity of images is that the wavelengths peoples eyes respond to varies. Younger people can typically see slightly further into the UV - presumably as the lens/cornea ages it absorbs more UV. I'm fairly sure the IR end varies too. These extended wavelengths aren't seen as different colours as they still stimulate the same 3 cells - so if your eye allows more UV to reach the retina the blue sensitive cones can be stimulated more than in someone whose eyes block the UV... It's possible there is also significant variation in the numbers of the different types of cones from one individual to another (I've never seen any studies into this)

The transmission spectra of my eyes changed significantly when I had a cataract operation a few years back. Until my brain adjusted to the change I found I had a distinct white balance variation between my left & right eyes!


Reply

DConvert 氏の書き込み:
visualopsins 氏の書き込み:
...especially solid state displays which can only radiate 3 specific wavelengths of light, which combine to fool the eye & brain into thinking there's a spectrum of colors, when in fact there are only 3 wavelengths...

Your eyes only contain 3 types of optical sensors (cells known as cones) used for determining colour. Spectral sensitivity for the cones do overlap but the peak wavelengths for each type are quite distinct (The other structures called rods are used in low light situations and have no colour sensitivity).
The three wavelengths chosen for optical displays are selected specifically because of how they interact with the cones so that the system can stimulate cones in the same way that any natural light would. So it's not surprising that the displays can match real world colours.

Part of the reason for the subjectivity of images is that the wavelengths peoples eyes respond to varies. Younger people can typically see slightly further into the UV - presumably as the lens/cornea ages it absorbs more UV. I'm fairly sure the IR end varies too. These extended wavelengths aren't seen as different colours as they still stimulate the same 3 cells - so if your eye allows more UV to reach the retina the blue sensitive cones can be stimulated more than in someone whose eyes block the UV... It's possible there is also significant variation in the numbers of the different types of cones from one individual to another (I've never seen any studies into this)

The transmission spectra of my eyes changed significantly when I had a cataract operation a few years back. Until my brain adjusted to the change I found I had a distinct white balance variation between my left & right eyes!


Great post, we covered the structure and working of the eye at university and I can't fault your description.


Reply

DConvert 氏の書き込み:
Until my brain adjusted to the change I found I had a distinct white balance variation between my left & right eyes!


Exactly here (in the brain) lies the real mystic because it's actually the interpreter of the information you get from your eyes. And that is also the reason why people often see the same (technically speaking) with their eyes and have totally different impressions. That will never change. That makes it also sometimes quite difficult to discuss objectively about photography. Actually we are all a little bit different.