MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

Canon EOS 1DS
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

Hi guys

I'm looking at a cheap 1DS at the moment, because it's full frame, doesn't require a mirror shave to use wide lenses and I understand the image quality produced is very good.

Does anyone have any experience of this camera? The things that put me off are potential speed issues (writing images to card, displaying on LCD), low ISO capability and the hugey size of the damn thing Laughing

If anyone has used one, I'd be interested in your views Smile

Many thanks


Reply

I hear rumours that the mkiv will be out soon, so I'd hang on for a bit.

1Ds is a serious bit of kit though and if you do get one, I'll have to call you `Sir'. Laughing


Reply

Hi,

I've never used a 1Ds or 1D. But if you look at DPreview, the size comparison to the Nikon D1x there is not much more to the Canon. So I really like the size of my Nikon D1x and it seems smaller to me every time I use my CJ 180 2.8 P6 on it. I have big hand and most DSLRs are to small for them but the D1x is absolutely perfect for me!

Here's the link to the size comparison: http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/CanonEOS1D/page22.asp

ciao,

Karhallarn


Reply

Jesito just bought one:
http://forum.mflenses.com/fisrt-tests-with-the-eos-1ds-and-the-zeiss-planar-50mm-1-7-t19417,highlight,1ds+planar.html


Reply

There's no way of knowing how many shots it has taken. The 1Ds was serious pro gear so it could have had a lot of use.


Reply

Thanks for all the info everyone, it's much appreciated Smile
Having weighed up many of the pros and cons, and had a good surf around the web, I've decided to save for a 2nd user 5D instead.

For me, I think the slow write speed and ISO capability is a killer. I don't really want to be restricted as to how and when I can use the camera.

It's a shame as I'm a little bit fearful of having to shave the mirror, but I'm hoping to find a 5D for around the £700.00 mark (shouldn't be a problem) so not TOO much of a waste if it all goes wrong Smile

In the meantime, I need to rationalise my lens collection to fund the upgrade, which given the sprawling mass of lenses, is probably a good thing Laughing


Reply

I don't think you'll regret getting a 5D, it is a superb camera.


Reply

1Ds is older, bigger, pro camera with possibly many more shutter actuations, being older and pro model, but may have been better cared for, and used in studio environment.

5D performance is better, has newer better sensor, may have fewer actuations, but shutter is newer designed for more actuations, 200K if memory serves. Higher ISO setting may be a bit of a stretch, I find it basically unusable, much noise unless bright scene, unless there's no other way to get acceptable shutter speed.

Maybe check around this website, beginning on this page. 5D is ranked 18 while 1Ds is ranked 41:

http://www.dxomark.com/index.php/eng/DxOMark-Sensor/Camera-rankings

Someplace on that website is a page to do between-camera side-by-side comparisons.

I got a used 5D and it has worked flawlessly. My wish is for Canon to produce a camera with the same features as 5D but using the 5DII sensor. Thinking all the extra features of 5DII such as video processing, cost of parts is dear. Canon could likely produce a basic 5D using 5DII sensor, introduce it at $1500 price point, and have another marketshare winner like the first Digital Rebel and the XT. Wouldn't that upset the crop-cam market? Very Happy


Reply

siriusdogstar 氏の書き込み:
Canon could likely produce a basic 5D using 5DII sensor, introduce it at $1500 price point, and have another marketshare winner like the first Digital Rebel and the XT. Wouldn't that upset the crop-cam market? Very Happy


Yes, but this "new" 5D would probably kill the 5D MkII.


Reply

Hi there,

I'm new here and fairly new manual focus lens user.
I only have 4 manual lenses and they are not the best but I'm head over heals in love to prime lenses Very Happy I can't afford expencive AF lens so this is a nice way to get quality lenses with affordable price.

Tomorrow I'll go check out few used Canon 5D's and hopefully get rid off my 450D which isn't the best for manual focus lens. What I've been wondering if the 5D's ISO 1600 is usable? What's the current price for well kept, moderately used 5D? I guess they are a bit overpriced in Finland atm..


Reply

From what I've seen, the 5D is EXCELLENT at ISO1600. The 5D Mk II is even better Smile


Reply

I did have the "classic" 5D and now the new 5D MKII.

IMHO the better ISO for the MKII gives the advantage of average one f/stop.
But the old 5D is excellent too under this aspect. With a good software denoiser, you will see only very small differences.

On the old one, you can also use the 3200 ISO Mode, which is usefull same as 1600 ISO on the crop cam like 400D. Not good, but in some situations "usefull"

Cheers
Henry


Reply

hinnerker 氏の書き込み:
But the old 5D is excellent too under this aspect. With a good software denoiser, you will see only very small differences.

On the old one, you can also use the 3200 ISO Mode, which is usefull same as 1600 ISO on the crop cam like 400D. Not good, but in some situations "usefull"

Cheers
Henry


Exactly, here is a 5D ISO 1600 shot (christmas), no post processing.
Lens Zeiss Planar 85mm f1.2, 1/60s :


Reply

And this is the 5D MK II with CZJ Biotar 1.5/75mm fully open at ISO 2500..
1/50... !! slightly unsharp in center, sorry but shows the noise performance well.

A crop ..




Cheers
Henry


Reply

yes, ive found the 5d fantastic at 1600. here are a couple with a much less expensive lens than above samples, a mir 35mm/2.0 shot wide open PLEASE CLICK ON EACH FOR BEST RESOLUTION:




Reply

siriusdogstar 氏の書き込み:
I got a used 5D and it has worked flawlessly. My wish is for Canon to produce a camera with the same features as 5D but using the 5DII sensor. Thinking all the extra features of 5DII such as video processing, cost of parts is dear. Canon could likely produce a basic 5D using 5DII sensor, introduce it at $1500 price point, and have another marketshare winner like the first Digital Rebel and the XT. Wouldn't that upset the crop-cam market? Very Happy


Boy howdy. Canon would sure make me one happy camper if they were to do such a thing. It would need Live View though.

What the market needs is a reasonably priced, no bells-no whistles FF DSLR. And Canon is in the best position to do it. But if they don't, somebody else will, and then they'll be playing catch-up.


Reply

First of all thank you all for replies! Yesterday I went to see 5D and I really liked it. I also tested 1Ds mkII but it would probably be too heavy for me with for example 24-80 2.8L( or I would have to go to gym more often;).) Now I'm wondering if I should save more money and buy a MKII instead of MKI. I'm not in a hurry because this aint the best time to take photos outdoors in Finland:)


Reply

well, about 5d vs 5dII, many more features and many more pixels, but many many more money!!! i got a really nice 5d for $1000usd. i havent seen any IIs for less than $2400usd. at least for me, i couldnt justify that amount of money. i have found the 5d to be just wonderful from any standpoint: great vf, great w mf lenses, very good battery life, great IQ, GREAT low light performance. and believe it or not, i picked up an extra stop on shutter speed as well over my sd14!


Reply

Maybe I should seek after such a deal from ebay because like I said they are a bit overpriced in here (like +1000€). Yeah 5D2 costs double and I know quite few lenses where to spend that money Wink and there aren't many used 5D2 for sale here.. I just have to be patient and wait for a good deal! Smile


Reply

That's impressive!