MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

AF stabilised body.
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

I'd like to ask you about the experience and your opinion about which would be the best price/quality system with stabilised body? I am somehow attracted towards the Sony last APS translucent mirror cameras , because the price of the fast Sony primes ( 35/1.8 , 50/1.Cool .
Vs the Only/Pana or Pentax offers.


Reply

Out of the 3 systems, only Sony has FF, that is if you are thinking of the fullframe route in the future. Some of the fast lens might be for crop body only though.


Reply

You think *these* sony lenses are cheap? Wait for the old Minolta glass,
and M42 adapted (unfortunately only M mode on most bodies)
(as usual, you may have to wait a bit for a bargain but there are
really many lenses in maf and m42 out there)

Can't really give a sales pitch for Sony (the "rootkit company") but the stabilizer is fun.
You should read up on the pecularities of the SLT and maybe
the dreaded flash issue before buying into this system)

Unfortunately I have no experience with competing systems, Pentax *sth?

Unfortunately


Reply

buerokratiehasser 氏の書き込み:
You think *these* sony lenses are cheap? Wait for the old Minolta glass,
and M42 adapted (unfortunately only M mode on most bodies)
(as usual, you may have to wait a bit for a bargain but there are
really many lenses in maf and m42 out there)

Can't really give a sales pitch for Sony (the "rootkit company") but the stabilizer is fun.
You should read up on the pecularities of the SLT and maybe
the dreaded flash issue before buying into this system)

Unfortunately I have no experience with competing systems, Pentax *sth?

Unfortunately

Around 110 £ a 1.8 prime in 35mm or 50mm for a new plastic fantastic AF is not a fortune besides the 250-350 £ for the fast only/pana primes or the Pentax ones. And the kit 18-55 seems good too. And of course there are the minoltas . But how are the last bodies ?


Reply

The Sony SLT, is a very good system, has a few downsides but many more upsides, the in body stabilzation is very good.
I like that i see more or less how the image will look in the EVF.


Reply

I have pentax k5, k7, k20 and use SR (shake reduction) for low light and long tele.
Adaptall-2, m42 and T2 are interchangeable between many system. Pentax's SR is really good,
especially when using with 500mm mirror. Any lens from 200mm and longer should have SR activated to gain 1-2 stops.

The specs say 4 stops, but that depends. I am ok with 50mm f1.2 at 1/10s.

k20 and k7 is old and not as good high iso, but the k5 still among the best high iso bodies.
They are trustworthy within theirs limit. k5 is also very consistent, but also depends on which AF lens to pair with.

for MF lenses, you need to change focus screen, I have katzeye, and calibrated with shims.
Also I have magnify eye piece.


Reply

eddieitman 氏の書き込み:
The Sony SLT, is a very good system, has a few downsides but many more upsides, the in body stabilzation is very good.
I like that i see more or less how the image will look in the EVF.


+1. The a58 is amazing value, for example.

Also, the non slt sony a580 would be a great camera to buy used in good condition.


Reply

hoanpham 氏の書き込み:
I have pentax k5, k7, k20 and use SR (shake reduction) for low light and long tele.
Adaptall-2, m42 and T2 are interchangeable between many system. Pentax's SR is really good,
especially when using with 500mm mirror. Any lens from 200mm and longer should have SR activated to gain 1-2 stops.

The specs say 4 stops, but that depends. I am ok with 50mm f1.2 at 1/10s.

k20 and k7 is old and not as good high iso, but the k5 still among the best high iso bodies.
They are trustworthy within theirs limit. k5 is also very consistent, but also depends on which AF lens to pair with.

for MF lenses, you need to change focus screen, I have katzeye, and calibrated with shims.
Also I have magnify eye piece.

How much is a 30mm fast prime for Pentax ?


Reply

the pentax smc K 30mm f2.8 is insanely sharp. I got mine approx 300usd, 4-5 yrs back.

I also have the 'distagon' pentax smc K 28mm f2, but it's pricy.

for AF, I recommend the FA35/2, 350-400usd, but worth every cent.
It's the lens to go and trustworthy. I don't have FA31/1.8, 'distagon' K28/2 replaced it

Another is sigma 30/1.4, sharp, a bit big, my copy is sharp.


Reply

i was just in the same position as you and i chose the oly epl5 for 3 reasons:
--m4/3 has a more complete line of fast high quality lenses than any other mirrorless system. specifically vs sony, the web is replete with pro reviews criticising their AF lenses as the weak point of that system.
--ergonomics: this is a matter of taste, but i find the sony cams too small and their lenses too big. imo its not a well balanced system at all. m4/3 has many excellent and compact lenses that much more 'fit' the compact cameras. the 12/2, 17/1.8, 20/1.7 and 45/1.8 are downright tiny, as fast as you can get, and universally excellently reviewed i can vouch for the 20&45, both are fantastic.
--again a matter of taste, but i just dont like sony rendering. YVMV. i find it flat, dull and full of blown highlights. oly is known for its wonderful color rendition.

you can get a really good deal on an epl5 which incorporates their latest sensor as well as an articulating lcd with 'touch, focus, shutter fire' capability which is an amazing tool for stealth street photography.
tony


Reply

If you want a system where you can find excellent native lenses cheap, go for Sony. The old Minolta AF lenses are available for peanuts and many of them are excellent. the 1.7/50 and 2.8/28 are both superb and very cheap. The 4/35-70 and 4/70-210 zooms are too, as is the 4.5-5.6/70-300. The 2.8/20 is superb too, but not so cheap. There's a very good review at lenstips comparing the old Minolta 1.7/50 to the new Sony 1.8/50, the Minolta wins, and given that lens is easy to find for 20-30ukp, it' a no-brainer. I used one for a decade or more on film and it never let me down, always sharp and contrasty, one of the best 50s around, still.

As for blown highlights etc, that's just poor technique, Sony sensors have just as good dynamic range as any other so with correct exposure, there's no reason to have blown highlights or any other issue, it's all about how you use the kit, not any inherent shortcomings in the kit itself. I could show you examples of flat, dull, boring output from the Leica M9 and wonderful, vivid output from a old 6MP camera, it's all about the shooter, not the camera. A bad workman blames his tools as they say. Wink

If you didn't need/want the in-body IS, I'd say go for Nikon because the old Nikon AF lenses are so cheap and there are several that are very much pro quality in IQ and build.


Reply

Thank you all .

Tony , I am fully agreeing your analyse on the oly but there is a small problem ... they are a bit too much priced for me. Again , I fully dislike the unbalance of the AF lenses on the Nex. Yes I use a Nex 3 and I like it with manual lenses , but for AF , I'd like a more classic volume balance on camera . I'd skip this if the Nex body would be stabilised , but it's not the case.And the AF Nex lenses seem to be not too good as far as I read on the serious reviewers.

Pentax is out of my reach because the price of the lenses and bodies.

The only one that remains is the Minolta/Sony system , as Ian said the lenses are good and more on the cheap side . I saw some good results /reviews on the latest translucent technology cameras.The downside is the bulk ,but the fast primes are cheaper than the other offerings , for a normal and a short tele prime.
Again , it seems that the kit 18-55 is very good vs the Nex version
These bodies share the sensors with the Nex cameras , but for some reason some reviews tend to say they are a little under the Nex series in the high Iso results.Don,'t understand why and not where if it's real.

Now , Why do I need fast primes AND stabilised ? The Nikon ,Canon ,Leica,Fuji shooters don't have stabilisation when using f 1.8 /1.4/1.2
Maybe I am wrong ?


Reply

There is one reason why the SLT bodies might be a little less good at higher ISOs - the translucent mirror cuts out some light, so probably Sony upped the ISO. Just because the cameras says ISO 1600 (for example) doesn't mean it is really ISO 1600, SOny could well be cheating and upping the actual figure to hide the light loss due to the mirror.

Whatever the case, I am sure that any Sony body with a 14mp or newer sensor will be more than good enough.

Just be careful to make sure the Steadyshot is still working, on many bodies you see for sale, it doesn't work anymore.

I agree with you about M4/3 being too small, I have big hands and the small m4/3 bodies just don't fit well in them. I much preferred the ergonomics of my EOS 10D to my 450D because the 10D was quite a bit bigger.

If you go for Sony, I'd start with 2.8/28, 1.7/50, 4/35-70 and either the 4/70-210 or 4.5-5.6/70-300, then you have most things covered and can add some other primes in future as cash allows.


Reply

its just a matter of taste teo. personally after using what i consider great compact cams like the gxr, x100 and oly, i just would not often want to use a bigger dslr setup. if that doesnt bother you then theres no reason not to go with the larger sony setup. and its also a matter of how many AF lenses you want. for me, ive got a lot of MF lenses, so i felt i only needed one or two AF lenses, so the expense was low, even with the oly lenses.

if you were of the mind, you could get a pretty cheap used epm2 and a used panny 20/1.7 together for $500usd. ive seen used oly 45/1.8, a great lens, go for $250 or less. the very good 14-42 kit lens is like $75. most combos are jacket pocketable and will produce stunning images. like everything else, its balancing personal preferences for size and resource allocation, right?

and im sure you know that some sensors commonly produce flat images or blow highlights.

good luck!


Reply

Personal experiences with Pentaxes and Olympus E-PM2.
All highly recommended. Stabilization works great.

My most used AF-sets (all bought used):
K-5 + Sigma 17-70 + 30/1.4 + 50/1.4

E-PM2 14/2.5 + 20/1.7 + 45/1.8

Don't agree on high costs compared to Sonys at least in this part of the world.


Reply

"Why fast primes AND stabilized?"


Uh, because you asked for it?


The MAF 50/1.7 for 30 pounds? It seems to go for 90 euros plus, more like plus...

I do not know how SLT "handles" the light loss, whether they show real exposure or whether they conveniently correct for the mirror so you may use your external meter; I never cared much because the mirror is said to eat only half a stop or so.
Also I am at a loss how good the new sensors are, I only know the A2xx CCD looks like mud at ISO 400 and like a compact above that, applying pixelpeeping standards, and that the newer Canikons are said to have insane high Iso performance for under 1000 bucks.

The smallest bodies for Minolta are the Dynax 3/4/5 line, unfortunately they have no stabilizer at all!

For the smallest M-AF DSLR, I would think maybe the A230 or A290 (non SLT)
These are still not pocket friendly, you can hold them in one large hand, but their sizable weight does make them tend to be left at home.

there used to be a fine list of all bodies on mhohner.de

Do you need to change lenses at all?


Reply

Ian , it was a little misunderstanding.I didn't wrote that I don't like the m4/3 because it's too small . In fact I much prefere the m4/3 bodies over the Nex because the balance between the body and the lens. In the case of the Nex system I find the lenses to be much too bulky for that body.Still , I am using the Nex 3 as a base for my manual focus lenses for obvious reasons ( register distance, ISO,1.5 crop).
And I much prefere a small pocketable system to carry everywhere. But a viewfinder is sometimes a good thing for AF shooting in the old fashion (which I miss sometimes ) ,and here I find the oly evf adding quite a sum over the initial price of the outfit.Even so, my question wasn't about a small pocketable camera , just stabilised.


Reply

I see. M4/3 is too small for my hands though, bu as I said, I have big hands. Smile


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 氏の書き込み:
I see. M4/3 is too small for my hands though, bu as I said, I have big hands. Smile

That's nice , you can be comfortable with a Pentacon 6 Laughing


Reply

yinyangbt 氏の書き込み:
iangreenhalgh1 氏の書き込み:
I see. M4/3 is too small for my hands though, bu as I said, I have big hands. Smile

That's nice , you can be comfortable with a Pentacon 6 Laughing


Yes, I like my P6 with Zodiac 30mm - a man's camera/lens combo fer sure! lol


Reply

I've had many Sony cameras in the past beginning with a300 and recently a850, all of them good cameras. Sadly (sadly, really) I had to move from Sony, because I needed better video, and they don't offer it even with their newest cameras. Minolta lenses were fine on lower MP cameras, while A77 with its 24mpx sensor was very demanding, only the best and not really cheap Minolta primes were good. As with any other system, if you want good quality you have to invest in glass; cheap 50/1.7 and 28/2.8 and the /4 lineup are rather mediocre performers by today's standards.
One thing that I miss are the Sony colors, IMHO a850/a900 had the best color rendering in the digital full frame segment. Their current a99 can't match it.

As for IBIS, Oly's 5-axis is way better than the Sony one. Also lens based images stabilizers are better.