| 前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ |
| 作成者 |
メッセージ |
Dusty-Lens
 登録日: 2020年2月23日 投稿: 76
|
 投稿日時: 木 10月 26, 2023 4:22 pm 件名: Best Zeiss Planar version |
|
 投稿日時: 木 10月 26, 2023 4:22 pm 件名: Best Zeiss Planar version |
|
|
Dusty-Lens wrote:
Which Zeiss Planar version has the most contrast, microcontrast, saturated colors and "3d pop"? (Basically the things that are often associated with Zeiss lenses and T* coatings.)
1) Contax G 45/2 is praised as extraordinary by many.
2) The ZM Planar 50/2 looks very good from what I see but is it indeed better than the Contax G 45/2?
Has anyone tried both? Any impressions will be helpful!
There are also the below, but they seem to match less the above criteria:
3) The ZF/ZE, CY, QBM 50/1.4 are highly regarded but from online examples seem to be a bit less punchy than the two above.
4) The CY 50/1.7 seems sharper than the 1.4 at equivalent apertures but again a bit less punchy than 1 and 2.
5) Or perhaps other classic lenses with even more contrast, microcontrast, saturated colors and "3d pop"? |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
calvin83
 登録日: 2009年4月12日 投稿: 7740 所在地: Hong Kong
|
 投稿日時: 木 10月 26, 2023 5:24 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 木 10月 26, 2023 5:24 pm 件名: |
|
|
calvin83 wrote:
Makro-Planar T* 50mm f/2 is also a pretty good lens if you want a versatile lens. _________________ The best lens is the one you have with you.
https://lensfever.com/
https://www.instagram.com/_lens_fever/ |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
stevemark
 登録日: 2011年4月29日 投稿: 5509 所在地: Switzerland
|
 投稿日時: 木 10月 26, 2023 6:24 pm 件名: Re: Best Zeiss Planar version |
|
 投稿日時: 木 10月 26, 2023 6:24 pm 件名: Re: Best Zeiss Planar version |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| Dusty-Lens 氏の書き込み: |
Which Zeiss Planar version has the most contrast, microcontrast, saturated colors and "3d pop"? (Basically the things that are often associated with Zeiss lenses and T* coatings.)
1) Contax G 45/2 is praised as extraordinary by many.
2) The ZM Planar 50/2 looks very good from what I see but is it indeed better than the Contax G 45/2? |
First caveat: I have never used these two lenses, so I can't say anything about them. I have, however, used a few other Zeiss ZM lenses (not my own, just borrowede for tests), and I know their mechanical qualities.
Most high perfomance normal lenses are either big or really big. And with "high performance" I mean things like the Otus 1.4/55. They are nearly impeccable at f2, using e. g. 43 MP FF sensors. I assume (!) neither the ZM 2/50 nor the G 2/45 would belong to this class; they rather seem to be "very good classical planars".
| Dusty-Lens 氏の書き込み: |
There are also the below, but they seem to match less the above criteria:
3) The ZF/ZE, CY, QBM 50/1.4 are highly regarded but from online examples seem to be a bit less punchy than the two above.
4) The CY 50/1.7 seems sharper than the 1.4 at equivalent apertures but again a bit less punchy than 1 and 2.
5) Or perhaps other classic lenses with even more contrast, microcontrast, saturated colors and "3d pop"? |
I know and own the CY 1.4/50 and 1.7/50 lenses (along with a few other normal lenses). Optically, neither of them is outstanding. Several other good vintage f1.4 and f1.7 normal lenses are as good or even slightly better (depending on the criteria you apply). Generally speaking, the differences in the optical performance of good vintage MF normal lenses are rather small (look at the bokeh, for instance: http://www.artaphot.ch/systemuebergreifend/objektive/479-standard-lens-bokeh-ii). I therefore would base the decision more on handling qualities such as size/weight, smoothness of focusing, size and texture of focusing ring, and operation of the aperture ring. Judging these properties is a very personal matter, and it's probably best if you can play around with some lenses before actrually buying them.
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
Dusty-Lens
 登録日: 2020年2月23日 投稿: 76
|
 投稿日時: 木 10月 26, 2023 9:48 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 木 10月 26, 2023 9:48 pm 件名: |
|
|
Dusty-Lens wrote:
| calvin83 氏の書き込み: |
| Makro-Planar T* 50mm f/2 is also a pretty good lens if you want a versatile lens. |
Yep, good point, thanks. |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
Dusty-Lens
 登録日: 2020年2月23日 投稿: 76
|
 投稿日時: 木 10月 26, 2023 9:54 pm 件名: Re: Best Zeiss Planar version |
|
 投稿日時: 木 10月 26, 2023 9:54 pm 件名: Re: Best Zeiss Planar version |
|
|
Dusty-Lens wrote:
| stevemark 氏の書き込み: |
| Dusty-Lens 氏の書き込み: |
Which Zeiss Planar version has the most contrast, microcontrast, saturated colors and "3d pop"? (Basically the things that are often associated with Zeiss lenses and T* coatings.)
1) Contax G 45/2 is praised as extraordinary by many.
2) The ZM Planar 50/2 looks very good from what I see but is it indeed better than the Contax G 45/2? |
First caveat: I have never used these two lenses, so I can't say anything about them. I have, however, used a few other Zeiss ZM lenses (not my own, just borrowede for tests), and I know their mechanical qualities.
Most high perfomance normal lenses are either big or really big. And with "high performance" I mean things like the Otus 1.4/55. They are nearly impeccable at f2, using e. g. 43 MP FF sensors. I assume (!) neither the ZM 2/50 nor the G 2/45 would belong to this class; they rather seem to be "very good classical planars".
| Dusty-Lens 氏の書き込み: |
There are also the below, but they seem to match less the above criteria:
3) The ZF/ZE, CY, QBM 50/1.4 are highly regarded but from online examples seem to be a bit less punchy than the two above.
4) The CY 50/1.7 seems sharper than the 1.4 at equivalent apertures but again a bit less punchy than 1 and 2.
5) Or perhaps other classic lenses with even more contrast, microcontrast, saturated colors and "3d pop"? |
I know and own the CY 1.4/50 and 1.7/50 lenses (along with a few other normal lenses). Optically, neither of them is outstanding. Several other good vintage f1.4 and f1.7 normal lenses are as good or even slightly better (depending on the criteria you apply). Generally speaking, the differences in the optical performance of good vintage MF normal lenses are rather small (look at the bokeh, for instance: http://www.artaphot.ch/systemuebergreifend/objektive/479-standard-lens-bokeh-ii). I therefore would base the decision more on handling qualities such as size/weight, smoothness of focusing, size and texture of focusing ring, and operation of the aperture ring. Judging these properties is a very personal matter, and it's probably best if you can play around with some lenses before actrually buying them.
S |
As a bit if a background I am a photographer for 2 decades and I have 100+ lenses. My question is specifically regarding contrast, microcontrast and colours from planars. I appreciate you feedback on the 1.4 and 1.7, thanks!
Btw, to the off-top points, I have the Otus and as an example I also have the Panason S Pro 50 1.4. The later is incomparably better in any optical aspect. But, again, my question here is not about that, nor about handling or something else, but a specific one. |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
thebbm
 登録日: 2013年12月11日 投稿: 294 所在地: France montpellier
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 7:17 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 7:17 am 件名: |
|
|
thebbm wrote:
i had contax planar 50 mm 1.7 , 1.4 , rollei QBM 50mm 1.7,
canon fd 50m 1.4
minolta pg 50m 1.4
for me the rollei QBM was way sharper than the 2 contaxt wide open
and canon fd 50m 1.4 i what i kept and sold all other |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
wolan
 登録日: 2015年6月30日 投稿: 605 所在地: Zurich
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 7:47 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 7:47 am 件名: |
|
|
wolan wrote:
I was impressed by the ZM Planar 50/2. In fact, this lens is the only one I regret to have sold. I am sure I'll buy it again
Regards _________________ https://www.flickr.com/photos/149089857@N03/ |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
Dusty-Lens
 登録日: 2020年2月23日 投稿: 76
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 9:03 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 9:03 am 件名: |
|
|
Dusty-Lens wrote:
| thebbm 氏の書き込み: |
i had contax planar 50 mm 1.7 , 1.4 , rollei QBM 50mm 1.7,
canon fd 50m 1.4
minolta pg 50m 1.4
for me the rollei QBM was way sharper than the 2 contaxt wide open
and canon fd 50m 1.4 i what i kept and sold all other |
Thanks for sharing your experience!
I have the QBM but its 50/1.8 which is actually an Ultron and 1.8 not 1.7 planar like the CY version. Really good, QBM Schneider-Kreuznach Rollei SL Xenon is sharper, but the Rollei has better contrast and bolder colour. |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
Dusty-Lens
 登録日: 2020年2月23日 投稿: 76
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 9:07 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 9:07 am 件名: |
|
|
Dusty-Lens wrote:
| wolan 氏の書き込み: |
I was impressed by the ZM Planar 50/2. In fact, this lens is the only one I regret to have sold. I am sure I'll buy it again
Regards |
Thanks fir the insight.
To me it's a choice between the ZM 50/2 and the Voigt VM Apo-lanthar 50/2. The Voigt is a modern design, very sharp but I would like to see how they compare in terms of contrast, microcontrast and colour.
Same for the 35 options - down between the ZM Biogon 35/2.8 and the VM Apo-lanthar 35/2. |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
Ultrapix
 登録日: 2012年1月6日 投稿: 689 所在地: Italy
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 9:38 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 9:38 am 件名: |
|
|
Ultrapix wrote:
Did you ever try the Contarex version? I didn't but I guess that it could be a good contender, If backlight resistance is not deemed a priority |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
thebbm
 登録日: 2013年12月11日 投稿: 294 所在地: France montpellier
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 9:46 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 9:46 am 件名: |
|
|
thebbm wrote:
| Dusty-Lens 氏の書き込み: |
| thebbm 氏の書き込み: |
i had contax planar 50 mm 1.7 , 1.4 , rollei QBM 50mm 1.7,
canon fd 50m 1.4
minolta pg 50m 1.4
for me the rollei QBM was way sharper than the 2 contaxt wide open
and canon fd 50m 1.4 i what i kept and sold all other |
Thanks for sharing your experience!
I have the QBM but its 50/1.8 which is actually an Ultron and 1.8 not 1.7 planar like the CY version. Really good, QBM Schneider-Kreuznach Rollei SL Xenon is sharper, but the Rollei has better contrast and bolder colour. |
my bad, i also have QBM 1,8 planar version not 1.7 |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
caspert79
 登録日: 2010年10月31日 投稿: 3912 所在地: The Netherlands
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 10:00 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 10:00 am 件名: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
Ok, this may be blasphemy but to be honest, I quite like the Pentax-M 50mm f/1.7, when it comes to saturated colors, contrast and 3D pop. Image taken wide open, no post processing. Double click for full size (focus is slightly before the eyes).
PentaxM5017169 by devoscasper, on Flickr
This image also shows 3D quality, contrast and saturated colors:
PentaxM5017DSC09983 by devoscasper, on Flickr |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
calvin83
 登録日: 2009年4月12日 投稿: 7740 所在地: Hong Kong
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 11:15 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 11:15 am 件名: |
|
|
calvin83 wrote:
For Sony E mount camera, the Loxia 50mm f/2.0 is pretty good opinion as it will perform better than the ZM version. _________________ The best lens is the one you have with you.
https://lensfever.com/
https://www.instagram.com/_lens_fever/ |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
Dusty-Lens
 登録日: 2020年2月23日 投稿: 76
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 1:18 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 1:18 pm 件名: |
|
|
Dusty-Lens wrote:
| caspert79 氏の書き込み: |
Ok, this may be blasphemy but to be honest, I quite like the Pentax-M 50mm f/1.7, when it comes to saturated colors, contrast and 3D pop. Image taken wide open, no post processing. Double click for full size (focus is slightly before the eyes).
PentaxM5017169 by devoscasper, on Flickr
This image also shows 3D quality, contrast and saturated colors:
PentaxM5017DSC09983 by devoscasper, on Flickr |
I've always found the Pentax/Takumar SMC (and now HD) coatings to be great, actually no worse than T* coatings from the same period. Your examples are really illuminating my initial question. Excellent contrast, microcontrast bold colours.
Do you find that the 50/1.7 has more of the above compared to other Pentax 50s?
I really like the pop and colour s if the 28/3.5 and 35/3.5 some of the best contrast and colour from that time.
Thanks for sharing! |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
caspert79
 登録日: 2010年10月31日 投稿: 3912 所在地: The Netherlands
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 5:48 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 5:48 pm 件名: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| Dusty-Lens 氏の書き込み: |
I've always found the Pentax/Takumar SMC (and now HD) coatings to be great, actually no worse than T* coatings from the same period. Your examples are really illuminating my initial question. Excellent contrast, microcontrast bold colours.
Do you find that the 50/1.7 has more of the above compared to other Pentax 50s?
I really like the pop and colour s if the 28/3.5 and 35/3.5 some of the best contrast and colour from that time.
Thanks for sharing! |
Yes, of all Pentax 50s I tried, the Pentax-M 50/1.7 is my favorite. Performance of the Pentax-M lenses is quite a mixed big IMO, some are great, others a disappointment.
Love the 100/2.8 as well.
Don’t know if the lenses you mention are the M or K version. In have the K 28/3.5, and it is great indeed. |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
mr_tibbs2004
 登録日: 2021年7月23日 投稿: 170 所在地: United States
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 8:53 pm 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 金 10月 27, 2023 8:53 pm 件名: |
|
|
mr_tibbs2004 wrote:
| caspert79 氏の書き込み: |
Ok, this may be blasphemy but to be honest, I quite like the Pentax-M 50mm f/1.7, when it comes to saturated colors, contrast and 3D pop. Image taken wide open, no post processing. Double click for full size (focus is slightly before the eyes).
PentaxM5017169 by devoscasper, on Flickr
This image also shows 3D quality, contrast and saturated colors:
PentaxM5017DSC09983 by devoscasper, on Flickr |
What camera was used? |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
Dusty-Lens
 登録日: 2020年2月23日 投稿: 76
|
 投稿日時: 土 10月 28, 2023 12:19 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 土 10月 28, 2023 12:19 am 件名: |
|
|
Dusty-Lens wrote:
| caspert79 氏の書き込み: |
| Dusty-Lens 氏の書き込み: |
I've always found the Pentax/Takumar SMC (and now HD) coatings to be great, actually no worse than T* coatings from the same period. Your examples are really illuminating my initial question. Excellent contrast, microcontrast bold colours.
Do you find that the 50/1.7 has more of the above compared to other Pentax 50s?
I really like the pop and colour s if the 28/3.5 and 35/3.5 some of the best contrast and colour from that time.
Thanks for sharing! |
Yes, of all Pentax 50s I tried, the Pentax-M 50/1.7 is my favorite. Performance of the Pentax-M lenses is quite a mixed big IMO, some are great, others a disappointment.
Love the 100/2.8 as well.
Don’t know if the lenses you mention are the M or K version. In have the K 28/3.5, and it is great indeed. |
M42 mount, SMC Takumars. I think that the M42 and K 28/3.5 are the same.
I really recommend the 35/3.5 absolutely overlooked gem. Dirt cheap. If you like the 28/3.5 (and 50/1.7) it is a worth addition to a set with beautiful IQ.
I had the 100/2.8 but sold it as I kept the Sonnar 100/3.5 and Nikkor 105/1.8 and Kaleinar 100/2.8.... and...and they became too many, so I sold several 100-105 lenses. ðŸ˜ðŸ˜‚ |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
D1N0
 登録日: 2012年8月7日 投稿: 2726
|
 投稿日時: 土 10月 28, 2023 12:49 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 土 10月 28, 2023 12:49 am 件名: |
|
|
D1N0 wrote:
| Dusty-Lens 氏の書き込み: |
M42 mount, SMC Takumars. I think that the M42 and K 28/3.5 are the same.
|
Many Takumars were carried over to SMC Pentax, but not the 28, that was a new design. Source: Pentaxforums.com
Super (and Multi-coated)Takumar:
SMC Pentax 28/3.5:
 _________________ pentaxian |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
Dusty-Lens
 登録日: 2020年2月23日 投稿: 76
|
 投稿日時: 土 10月 28, 2023 12:51 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 土 10月 28, 2023 12:51 am 件名: |
|
|
Dusty-Lens wrote:
| D1N0 氏の書き込み: |
| Dusty-Lens 氏の書き込み: |
M42 mount, SMC Takumars. I think that the M42 and K 28/3.5 are the same.
|
Many Takumars were carried over to SMC Pentax, but not the 28, that was a new design. Source: Pentaxforums.com
Super (and Multi-coated)Takumar:
SMC Pentax 28/3.5:
 |
Yes, indeed. It is different. The results looked indistinguishable to me though, but it is a minor change so that might explain it. |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
caspert79
 登録日: 2010年10月31日 投稿: 3912 所在地: The Netherlands
|
 投稿日時: 土 10月 28, 2023 8:31 am 件名: |
|
 投稿日時: 土 10月 28, 2023 8:31 am 件名: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| mr_tibbs2004 氏の書き込み: |
What camera was used? |
Sorry, I missed your question. Sony A7RII. |
|
| トップへ戻る |
|
 |
|
|