MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

the choice of bigger format folder
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

Questions for people who have experienced the following cameras;

- Moskva 5,

- Voigtländer RF,

- and Voigtländer Bessa 1

Which one had 'the best' lens in terms of sharpness?

I didn't have the opportunity to thoroughly use any of these cameras as I would have liked for landscapes (kind of/similar to Ansel Adams),
but I need to make a decision and stick with one and sell other 2,
find some the time and get out of the concrete surrounded life for good.
Or for a longer period


Reply

alex_d 氏の書き込み:

I didn't have the opportunity to thoroughly use any of these cameras as I would have liked for landscapes (kind of/similar to Ansel Adams),
but I need to make a decision and stick with one and sell other 2


I can't really answer you quesition, but ...

1) Check the three cameras yourself (and kindly inform us about the results, too ...). No need for a fancy subject, but a good opportunity to practise a reliably and reproducible workstyle. Get three rolls of b/w film, and shoot three images each (wide open, f8, f16) of a landscape / archtitecture scenery, plus three of a "close up" (e. g. persons). Examoning the negatives should give you a good idea about the performance of these cameras and their lenses

2) Don't expect wonders à la "Ansel Adams". Early on when I received my very first 24 MP FF Sony A900 I compared it with a Zeiss Super Ikonta 6x9cm, equipped with Zeiss Tessar 3.5/10.5 cm. I was pretty astoished to see that the 24 MP FF camera was outperforming the Ikonta / Tessar by far.

3) The famous Ansel Adams images ususally were taken on 8x10" film. Those cameras are huge ...!

Again - check your cameras carefully and let us know Wink

S


Reply

The Moskva 5 was a Super-Ikonta descendant, and is ready for 6x9
I dont know whether the lens (105 mm) is a tessar clone?

The Voigtlanders, which lens do you have in those?
Skopars are decent and quite sharp if stopped down to f/8 or so

I'm a sucker for the cursive V cameras, so if you decide to sell that Bessa let me know


Reply

@stevemark

well .. this 1) -> Sure, I know this; it's a no-brainer.
However, it takes too much time, and it's very, very boring for me.
That's why I asked it the way I did.

2) i'll correct it "I want to spend some quality time in nature/mountains, and I also want to use a 6x9 format camera in case I see something worth of photographing .. that could be reassembled as Ansel Adams type of taking pictures" Smile

@titrisol70
yes its a Tessar sold as Industar-24, 105mm f 3.5 lens.
Voightlanders are with plane all-round skopars, not heliars ( = internet wet dream voightlander II)

what is "cursive V camera" btw?

if you are interested .. i suppose you would like to see some pics of cameras Smile


Reply

Voigtlander used to stamp a cursive V in the front of the cameras, in their logo
Skopars are Tessars made by V, very good lenses


Reply

alex_d 氏の書き込み:

- Moskva 5,



I had quite mediocre, to say no worse, experience with "Moskow" cameras in general, and their lenses in particular. But generally it is believed, that 2 and 4 are better then 5 models.

alex_d 氏の書き込み:
- Voigtländer RF,


I have one prewar with uncounted Heliar. It is evidently better then even Super Ikontas. To leave Moskow camera alone. And my experience with Heliar lenses were very nice. However, I believe that postwar cameras with the coated lens should be preferred. [/b]


Reply

titrisol70 氏の書き込み:
Voigtlander used to stamp a cursive V in the front of the cameras, in their logo
Skopars are Tessars made by V, very good lenses


on non of my voigtlanders is anywhere a V to be seen, on this bessa RF is unclear what lens is it

I think i have some V's on old alu Jena tessar's



引用:
I believe that postwar cameras with the coated lens should be preferred.


a postwar folder with coated lens ? maybe only as is a Fuji


Reply

alex_d 氏の書き込み:

on non of my voigtlanders is anywhere a V to be seen, on this bessa RF is unclear what lens is it

Not on the font?


Not even on the name at the top of the camera?


PostWar Skopars, were recalculated and coated and marked as Color-Skopar
https://web.archive.org/web/20120710041141/http://www.taunusreiter.de/Cameras/Bessa_RF_histo.html

The 105/3.5 is very capable


最終編集: titrisol70、木 10月 31, 2024 12:39 pm、計 1 回


Reply

alex_d 氏の書き込み:


a postwar folder with coated lens ? maybe only as is a Fuji


Voigtlander Bessa II 6x9 Rangefinder Color Heliar 105mm f3.5

https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/cywAAOSwBKFnGFOQ/s-l1600.webp


Reply

[quote="stevemark"]
alex_d 氏の書き込み:


3) The famous Ansel Adams images ususally were taken on 8x10" film. Those cameras are huge ...!

S


4 x5 would be a good compromise


Reply

Hmm. I'm a certified ignorant barbarian. I took the course, passed the exam and have the certificate.

As a CIB, I find the cameras the OP listed not very interesting or even useful. I have a couple of similar folding cameras that might fit in a pocket, including an Ensign Selfix 820 for "6x9," a poor metric approximation to 2.25" x 3.25", and a Voigtlaender Perkeo II for "6x6," a metric approximation to 2.25" x 2.25". Both have fixed lenses, are therefore somewhat limited. I've never got a satisfactorily sharp image with either, regardless of aperture, shutter speed and support. A Perkeo print, soft or not, is up on the wall. Sharpness is overrated.

I prefer interchangeable lens cameras even though 6x9ers don't fit most pockets. For example, the humble Century Graphic, which can be used without effort with lenses as short as the 35/4.5 Apo Grandagon and as long as ~ 250 mm tele lenses. In addition, it has minimal decentering movements, of which the most useful is ~ 19 mm of front rise. This is somewhat useful for eliminating boring foregrounds and converging verticals.


Reply

how much do you want to spend?

ここをクリックしてeBayで見る


Reply

danfromm 氏の書き込み:


I prefer interchangeable lens cameras even though 6x9ers don't fit most pockets. .


There is description of my considering of similar dilemma:

https://forum.mflenses.com/linhof-super-technika-vs-topcon-horseman-t84369.html


Reply

Alex, thanks for the reply and the link.

The Linhof and Horseman cameras you wrote about are more capable that the Graphic I mentioned. In particular, they have cammed rangefinders, unlike the Graphic, whose rangefinders (two different ones were fitted to 2x3 Graphics) are really usable with only one lens. Against that, the little Graphic is less expensive and can be focused using the ground glass.

All of these press/technical cameras will fit only in enormous pockets. For some users this is a serious disadvantage.


Reply

danfromm 氏の書き込み:


All of these press/technical cameras will fit only in enormous pockets.


Anyway all of them really need - for the proper results, a tripod. Which would not go in any pocket.


Reply

danfromm 氏の書き込み:
Alex, thanks for the reply and the link.

The Linhof and Horseman cameras you wrote about are more capable that the Graphic I mentioned.


There is my story with the Graphic

https://forum.mflenses.com/speed-graphic-aero-ektar-t81232.html


Reply

danfromm 氏の書き込み:
Hmm.
...
I find the cameras the OP listed not very interesting or even useful. I have a couple of similar folding cameras ...
...
I've never got a satisfactorily sharp image with either, regardless of aperture, shutter speed and support. ... Sharpness is overrated.



Exacly my experience too, after careful testing of my Super Ikonta 6x9cm equipped with CZJ Tessar 3.5/10.5 cm.



LittleAlex 氏の書き込み:
danfromm 氏の書き込み:


All of these press/technical cameras will fit only in enormous pockets.


Anyway all of them really need - for the proper results, a tripod. Which would not go in any pocket.


Indeed.

That's why I use my 24 MP FF DSLRs with in-body stabilizsation - or the 50 MP class mirrorless FF cameras, also with in-body stabillization ... You can get the resolution of a 4 x 5 inch slide with those digital cameras, even without tripod (as long as there's dayllight).

S


Reply

LittleAlex 氏の書き込み:
danfromm 氏の書き込み:


All of these press/technical cameras will fit only in enormous pockets.


Anyway all of them really need - for the proper results, a tripod. Which would not go in any pocket.


They were made to be shot hand-held and were used that way by working professionals.

Graphics' tubular viewfinders accept masks for other focal lengths than normal, adjust for parallax and even accept a supplementary lens for w/a lenses. Graphics' wire frame viewfinders also adjust for various focal lengths. Very useful cameras even though not as capable as more modern equivalents.

Using movements with press/technical cameras does indeed require a tripod. So does close-up work. In theory a focusing frame should make close-up work possible hand-held. In theory. In practice, at least for me, unusable.

stevemark's comments are right. In practice digital is much easier to use and yields results that are better than good enough.


Reply

Primo Voco

Let's see the comments, in a nutshell (randomized);
- '..not sharp..'
- ' use 8 x 10 ..'
- '.. you can't do it/you should not use it because I can't do it ..'
- '.. not sharp..'
- ' ..use 4 x 5..'
- '.. you need multiple lenses..'
- ' .. sharpness is overrated..'
- '.. use 5k - 10k worth of modern digital tools to have a sharp ..'
- '..not sharp..'
- '.. needs stabilization..'
- '..not sharp..'


Reply

alex_d 氏の書き込み:
Primo Voco

Let's see the comments, in a nutshell (randomized);
...
- '.. use 5k - 10k worth of modern digital tools to have a sharp ..'
...


Wrong citation indeed.

Those 24 MP SLRs I still use today for high quality calendar photos (40x60cm print size) are selling for 200-300 CHF (EUR/USD) here in Switzerland. And the corresponding Zeiss 2.8/24-70mm goes for 250-350 CHF. Certainly not 5k - 10k worth!!

I hope this clarification is useful.

S


EDIT
A Voigtländer Bessa I 6x9cm with f3.5 Skopar or a Zeiss Ikon Super Ikonta 6x9cm with f3.5 Tessar is as expensive as a used 24MP SLR these days ... so if you want excellent high res images, the choice is easy. Add a cheap MinAF 1.7/50mm to a used Sony A900, take images at f5.6 and get the resolution of a 4x5 inch slide ...!


Reply

@stevemark

i red somewhere ' a sony and mid format (digital)..' and that was my association to 5-10k

now i read that sony a900 is an 'ancient' digital camera. Im not aware much of sonies except that they could be very expensive (when new)

Anyway, that was not the reply that 'helps' me making a choice; instead, it shifts the problem to another path and possibly creates more hardware issues, and im trying to get rid of the hardware.

I often notice on this forum (I could be guilty of this as well..) that there are rarely direct answers to the problems posed.
Instead, people tend to offer alternative solutions, explaining that there are other ways to approach the issue.


Reply

alex_d 氏の書き込み:
@stevemark

i red somewhere ' a sony and mid format (digital)..' and that was my association to 5-10k

now i read that sony a900 is an 'ancient' digital camera. Im not aware much of sonies except that they could be very expensive (when new)

Anyway, that was not the reply that 'helps' me making a choice; instead, it shifts the problem to another path and possibly creates more hardware issues, and im trying to get rid of the hardware.

I often notice on this forum (I could be guilty of this as well..) that there are rarely direct answers to the problems posed.
Instead, people tend to offer alternative solutions, explaining that there are other ways to approach the issue.


Alex, if the V cameras have Skopars then they are equivalent to the Industar so optically the same ->Image quality is going to be very similar (if they are all in good shape)

Walk around your neighborhood with each camera and pretend to take pics, see which one feels better in your hand, in your pocket, etc and then choose based on that
While hiking that feel and the weight difference are very important (I prefer the 6x6 Isolettes becasue of that)


Reply

Alex, since you had written ...

alex_d 氏の書き込み:
Questions for people who have experienced the following cameras;
...
Which one had 'the best' lens in terms of sharpness?
... I would have liked for landscapes (kind of/similar to Ansel Adams),


... I (wrongly) assumed that you were looking for a camera capable of shooting images "similar to Ansel Adams" - that would mean high resolution and a wide dynamic range.


alex_d 氏の書き込み:
@stevemark
...
Anyway, that was not the reply that 'helps' me making a choice; instead, it shifts the problem to another path and possibly creates more hardware issues, and im trying to get rid of the hardware.


I didn't realize that you main issue was getting rid of hardware ...

Sorry about that misunderstanding.

S


Reply

stevemark,

Indeed, it's about getting rid of too much hardware and keeping only 'the best' items:
if it is possible to choose it without really enjoying them all.

Well, i made my assumptions, you made your too, so we’re even on that one.
As I mentioned earlier, reading is one thing, understanding is another, and replying is yet another.
Very often, these three processes do not work together in harmony.