MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

Ricoh GXR-M focus peaking/focus assist
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

Hello people ,i wanted to know from people (like KUUAN)who own both Nex and Ricoh GXR to give me a comparative of Focus peaking/focus assist feature between NEX and Ricoh GXR.


Reply

shhhhhhh!!! NO one!!!!!!


Reply

I know only 1 or 2 GRX owner here , so don't surprise if no answer


Reply

raay04 氏の書き込み:
Hello people ,i wanted to know from people (like KUUAN)who own both Nex and Ricoh GXR to give me a comparative of Focus peaking/focus assist feature between NEX and Ricoh GXR.


very good question Raay, thank you for that!

I have tried to point out some differences here and there, usually there is no response. My impression from forums, also this one, is that most don't differentiate between cameras when discussing focus assist, specially focus peaking. It is as if they believed that observations they make about focus peaking of their own camera automatically applies to other cameras too! This is erroneous indeed, eventually, with more and more cameras offering it, more people will want to compare.

I have been thinking of doing a write-up how Sony NEX5N and Ricoh GXR M compare, specially about the implementations of focus assist but haven't found enough impetus to try, I guess mostly because of lack of interest. It also is quite complex, difficult to explain and for people to grasp if they lack experience of use, so please give me some time! ( it's past midnight, I have a flight to catch early morning and shall be a bit busy for a few days to come )

Tom Caldwell, a member of dpreview forums who owns both GXR M and NEX6, has voiced his opinions here and there, that's two I found right now, but searching you should find more:
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/52136194
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/51548381
a quote from there which sums up 'some' aspects very well, quote: "But ultimately as far as focus peaking goes with the NEX we are lucky that the lcd is quite sharp at max magnification and it might be argued that then focus peaking is not so necessary. My Ricoh focus peaking experience argues otherwise."
there also had been some observations, including mine, in this forum already: http://forum.mflenses.com/comparison-m-lenses-on-nex5n-and-ricoh-m-module-t46238,start,15.htmlhttp://forum.mflenses.com/comparison-m-lenses-on-nex5n-and-ricoh-m-module-t46238,start,15.html

cheers, andreas


Reply

kuuan 氏の書き込み:
raay04 氏の書き込み:
Hello people ,i wanted to know from people (like KUUAN)who own both Nex and Ricoh GXR to give me a comparative of Focus peaking/focus assist feature between NEX and Ricoh GXR.


very good question Raay, thank you for that!

I have tried to point out some differences here and there, usually there is no response. My impression from forums, also this one, is that most don't differentiate between cameras when discussing focus assist, specially focus peaking. It is as if they believed that observations they make about focus peaking of their own camera automatically applies to other cameras too! This is erroneous indeed, eventually, with more and more cameras offering it, more people will want to compare.

I have been thinking of doing a write-up how Sony NEX5N and Ricoh GXR M compare, specially about the implementations of focus assist but haven't found enough impetus to try, I guess mostly because of lack of interest. It also is quite complex, difficult to explain and for people to grasp if they lack experience of use, so please give me some time! ( it's past midnight, I have a flight to catch early morning and shall be a bit busy for a few days to come )

Tom Caldwell, a member of dpreview forums who owns both GXR M and NEX6, has voiced his opinions here and there, that's two I found right now, but searching you should find more:
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/52136194
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/51548381
a quote from there which sums up 'some' aspects very well, quote: "But ultimately as far as focus peaking goes with the NEX we are lucky that the lcd is quite sharp at max magnification and it might be argued that then focus peaking is not so necessary. My Ricoh focus peaking experience argues otherwise."
there also had been some observations, including mine, in this forum already: http://forum.mflenses.com/comparison-m-lenses-on-nex5n-and-ricoh-m-module-t46238,start,15.htmlhttp://forum.mflenses.com/comparison-m-lenses-on-nex5n-and-ricoh-m-module-t46238,start,15.html

cheers, andreas


Thanks Andreas, I was in a discussion with Tom Caldwell in Dpreview yesterday ,he actually praises the Mode2 focus assist in Ricoh GXR-m module!!! I will certainly wait for your write up, though i dont have any wish to get a GXR-M ,well its Not available in India anyway rightnow!! Razz


Reply

raay04 氏の書き込み:
kuuan 氏の書き込み:
raay04 氏の書き込み:
Hello people ,i wanted to know from people (like KUUAN)who own both Nex and Ricoh GXR to give me a comparative of Focus peaking/focus assist feature between NEX and Ricoh GXR.


very good question Raay, thank you for that!

I have tried to point out some differences here and there, usually there is no response. My impression from forums, also this one, is that most don't differentiate between cameras when discussing focus assist, specially focus peaking. It is as if they believed that observations they make about focus peaking of their own camera automatically applies to other cameras too! This is erroneous indeed, eventually, with more and more cameras offering it, more people will want to compare.

I have been thinking of doing a write-up how Sony NEX5N and Ricoh GXR M compare, specially about the implementations of focus assist but haven't found enough impetus to try, I guess mostly because of lack of interest. It also is quite complex, difficult to explain and for people to grasp if they lack experience of use, so please give me some time! ( it's past midnight, I have a flight to catch early morning and shall be a bit busy for a few days to come )

Tom Caldwell, a member of dpreview forums who owns both GXR M and NEX6, has voiced his opinions here and there, that's two I found right now, but searching you should find more:
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/52136194
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/51548381
a quote from there which sums up 'some' aspects very well, quote: "But ultimately as far as focus peaking goes with the NEX we are lucky that the lcd is quite sharp at max magnification and it might be argued that then focus peaking is not so necessary. My Ricoh focus peaking experience argues otherwise."
there also had been some observations, including mine, in this forum already: http://forum.mflenses.com/comparison-m-lenses-on-nex5n-and-ricoh-m-module-t46238,start,15.htmlhttp://forum.mflenses.com/comparison-m-lenses-on-nex5n-and-ricoh-m-module-t46238,start,15.html

cheers, andreas


Thanks Andreas, I was in a discussion with Tom Caldwell in Dpreview yesterday ,he actually praises the Mode2 focus assist in Ricoh GXR-m module!!! I will certainly wait for your write up, though i dont have any wish to get a GXR-M ,well its Not available in India anyway rightnow!! Razz


haha, yes, Raay, I later realized that you had been in one of the ongoing discussions with Tom that I had linked to. He is very eloquent, there is hardly anything I can add, really...but I shall try a short version Wink


Reply

Raay you have been active in that thread about focus peaking at dpreview and now I have been too. Once again it has been a fruitless and tiring exercise and right now I really don't feel like putting forward me experience and thoughts once again.
For anyone interested please read here: http://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/3544244

cheers, andreas


Reply

kuuan 氏の書き込み:
Raay you have been active in that thread about focus peaking at dpreview and now I have been too. Once again it has been a fruitless and tiring exercise and right now I really don't feel like putting forward me experience and thoughts once again.
For anyone interested please read here: http://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/3544244

cheers, andreas


Okay cool ,no problemo
Laughing Laughing


Reply

My observations, to note that all are based on using the respective electronic viewfinders, not the LCDs ( which I hardly ever do )

Magnification:

Nex5N:
- dedicated button engages magnification.
- pushing once magnifies x4.8, pushing twice x9.5, third time cancels it.
- once magnification is activated the 4 way cursor functions to scroll the magnified portion.
- half pressing the release cancels magnification, if focus peaking is activated it doesn't cancel it.

Ricoh GXR M:
- various buttons can be programmed to engage magnification.
- one must decide in the menu first if one wants magnification of x2, x4 or x8.
- to scroll the magnified portion one must first activate the 2 way controller by the socalled 'adj. lever'.
- half pressing the release cancels both magnification and focus peaking, but only for the time one keeps half pressed, both magnification and focus peaking come back when finger is taken off the release.

my personal observations / comparison:
- the button to activated the magnification on the NEX is very awkwardly positioned. One can program one other button but then looses direct access to one of the most basic settings needed, so it's not really an alternative. A clear point for Ricoh, I can program a number of buttons, also much better located ones, without loosing direct access to the most important settings
- About pushing the button twice giving double magnification as on NEX or canceling magnification and having to preset multiplication factor in menu: In practice so far I mostly want the x9.5 magnification on the NEX, that is I have to press the button twice. On the GXR I'd need to press only once for x8, but so far I have set magnification to x4 only which has been sufficient ( that must be because of how different focus peaking works, resp. on the NEX I less rely on the focus peaking but what I see in the excellent resolution EVF, while on the GXR with it's less resolution EVF I rely more on the focus peaking which is more accurate. plan to use x8 for a while now and maybe add my experience with that later ).
- The NEX magnification automatically activating the 4 way controller to scroll the magnified portion makes me use that function much more often than on the GXR. Many times however, without me having intended that, when magnifying I find the magnified portion to be in a far corner and that disturbs and delays. Hm..maybe I do something wrong? As it is the NEX way 'should' be better, but in practice both are not ideal.
- The GXR cancels magnification and focus peaking when half pressing the release, but both come back when taking the finger off the release, one can 'toggle' between magnification + focus peaking and 'normal' view'. The NEX keeps focus peaking but cancels magnification for good when half pressing the release. If one wants magnification back one again must press - the awkwardly positioned - button which usually even makes me move the whole camera. That is a HUGE point in favor of the Ricoh! ( though I have learned that most users that haven't experienced it can't quite grasp it ) The toggling between magnified view and 'normal' view is very helpful, specially for fast fine tuning focus on moving objects / people

Focus peaking:

NEX has three levels of sensitivity and three colors one can choose in the menu
GXR has two modes. One is similar to the NEX mode but in only one color, white, and one cannot change sensitivity neither. Mode 2 makes a B&W image which reportedly is even more precise, but I hardly ever have used it and cannot comment.

My personal observations:
NEX focus peaking is reliable only if sensitivity is set to 'low'. Medium and high settings will show much deeper areas in focus than really are in focus. For most precise focusing also best to set the lens to wide open.
GXR focus peaking is similar to the NEX's set to 'low' but the lines are more easily visible. This should not be confused with 'medium' and 'high' sensitivities on a NEX which also show up more easily but lack in precision. In practice GXR focus peaking allows for faster focusing with very similar hit rate than with the NEX set to 'low', that is near to 100%.

and: I find this very remarkable. When I first looked through the EVF of the Ricoh, being used to the one of the NEX5N, I was quite taken aback because of how much smaller it is and how much less resolution it has. Therefore I thought that focusing will be much more difficult on the GXR. However slowly I realized that focus peaking works that much better that it outdoes the technical deficits of the EVF.
Or in other words, there is hope for a future offering with the advantages of both Very Happy

-------------------


( For anyone interested in technical theories behind focus peaking that earlier linked thread at dpreview is highly recommended! I only half understand them, haven't tried much neither, I am a practical guy and leave the theories to the camera makers.
I care about actual use, have taken 10.000nds of photos using a variety of manual lenses and focus assists of both cameras. What I share is based on that experience only.
As often I may not have phrased well and find it unfortunate that my observations get buried by long posts of theories. Theories explaining why Ricoh's Mode 2 is of no use and Mode 1 inferior to that of NEX's implementation, all have their logic and are written by a very knowledgeable guy. But he only has used NEX and never even has had the Ricoh in his hands Shocked )


最終編集: kuuan、土 9月 14, 2013 8:44 am、計 2 回


Reply

kuuan 氏の書き込み:
Magnification:

Nex5N:
- dedicated button engages magnification.
- pushing once magnifies x4.8, pushing twice x9.5, third time cancels it.
- once magnification is activated the 4 way cursor functions to scroll the magnified portion.
- half pressing the release cancels magnification, if focus peaking is activated it doesn't cancel it.

Ricoh GXR M:
- various buttons can be programmed to engage magnification.
- one must decide in the menu first if one wants magnification of x2, x4 or x8.
- to scroll the magnified portion one must first activate the 2 way controller by the socalled 'adj. lever'.
- half pressing the release cancels both magnification and focus peaking, but only for the time one keeps half pressed, both magnification and focus peaking come back when finger is taken off the release.

my personal observations / comparison:
- the button to activated the magnification on the NEX is very awkwardly positioned. One can program one other button but then looses direct access to one of the most basic settings needed, so it's not really an alternative. A clear point for Ricoh, I can program a number of buttons, also much better located ones, without loosing direct access to the most important settings
- I am undecided if I prefer pushing the button twice giving double magnification as on NEX or if it cancels magnification as on GXR. In theory the NEX way should be superior, in practice, because I find focus peaking on the Ricoh more reliable, the GXR way is sufficient too.
- The NEX magnification automatically activating the 4 way controller to scroll the magnified portion makes me use that function much more often than on the GXR. Many times however, without me having intended that, when magnifying I find the magnified portion to be in a far corner and that disturbs and delays. Hm..both not ideal.
- The GXR cancels magnification and focus peaking when half pressing the release, but both come back when taking the finger off the release, one can 'toggle' between magnification + focus peaking and 'normal' view'. The NEX keeps focus peaking but cancels magnification for good when half pressing the release. If one wants magnification back one again must press - the awkwardly positioned - button which usually even makes me move the whole camera. That is a HUGE point in favor of the Ricoh! ( though I have learned that most users that haven't experienced it can't quite grasp it ) The toggling between magnified view and 'normal' view is very helpful, specially for fast fine tuning focus on moving objects / people

Focus peaking:

NEX has three levels of sensitivity and three colors one can choose in the menu
GXR has two modes. One is similar to the NEX mode but in only one color, white, and one cannot change sensitivity neither. Mode 2 makes a B&W image which reportedly is even more precise, but I hardly ever have used it and cannot comment.

My personal observations:
NEX focus peaking is reliable only if sensitivity is set to 'low'. Medium and high settings will show much deeper areas ion focus than really are in focus. for most precise focusing also best to set the lens to wide open.
GXR focus peaking is similar to the NEX's set to 'low' but the lines are more easily visible. This should not be confused with 'medium' and 'high' sensitivities on a NEX which also show more easily but are not precise. In practice GXR focus peaking allows for faster focusing with very similar hit rate than with the NEX set to 'low', that is near to 100%.

and: I find this very remarkable. When I first looked through the EVF of the Ricoh, being used to the one of the NEX5N, I was quite taken aback because of how much smaller it is and how much less resolution it has. Therefore I thought that focusing will be much more difficult on the GXR. However slowly I realized that focus peaking works that much better that it more than outdoes the technical deficits of the EVF.
Or in other words, there is hope for a future offering with the advantages of both Very Happy

-------------------


( For anyone interested in technical theories behind focus peaking that earlier linked thread at dpreview is highly recommended! I only half understand them, haven't tried much neither, I am a practical guy and leave the theories to the camera makers.
I care about actual use, have taken 10.000nds of photos using a variety of manual lenses and focus assists of both cameras. What I share is based on that experience only.
As often I may not have phrased well and find it unfortunate that my observations get buried by long posts of theories. Theories explaining why Ricoh's Mode 2 is of no use and Mode 1 inferior to that of NEX's implementation, all have their logic and are written by a very knowledgeable guy. But he only has used NEX and never even has had the Ricoh in his hands Shocked )


Thanks for sharing your observations , i also do feel that the magnification button on the nex is awkwardly placed, a few more buttons on the nex would have been quite welcome ,but sony decided a non pro look!!!! i hope sony do provide a sort a firmware upgrade to get more better focus assist ,but i dont think thats gonna happen cause unlike Ricoh M mount module sony has to sell OEM lenses , and i dont think they are thrilled by people buying more vintage lenses than their own lenses!!!!


Reply

Actually I believe that Sony does have legacy lens users in mind. A NEX exposes any adapted lens just as well as if it was an E mount lens that communicates with the camera, and I think it does that not only by 'chance' or 'mistake'. Even the GXR M which is specially made for manual lenses that don't communicate with the camera doesn't do it as well. There are more advantages of the NEX, it's faster, has a more universal mount and less noise specially at high ISO. Could I only keep one camera, because it is more universally useable and more responsive, I'd choose the NEX. I should have mentioned that at the thread at dpreview, maybe that would make it easier for NEX users to accept that an other make might have the edge in focus peaking Wink Having both for now during day it's usually the Ricoh and at low light the Sony.
Oh, low light, there is something I had forgotten to mention: At low light the EVF of the GXR becomes much more noisy than the EVF of the NEX5N, and it becomes very difficult to focus. The NEX does a very good job there, makes focusing easier than with the OVF of my Pentax dSLR + split screen even at very low light.


Reply

Tom Caldwell, in a separate thread at dpreview, now illustrated the difference of focus peaking between NEX and Mode 2 of the GXR. I just wished he also had included Mode 1, but nevertheless it will give some idea, specially of an issue he often mentions but I never did, the NEX shows a lot in focus when in 'full view' but much less, hardly anything when magnified, of course specially when set to 'low' with a wide lens wide open, though this is the setting one wants to get the focus right:
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/3546511#forum-post-52163661


Reply

Interesting to hear your thoughts on peaking. I just checked and I have my peaking level set to middle (after some trials way back). Since you advocate low setting so strongly, I'll give it some more testing time.


Reply

fermy 氏の書き込み:
Interesting to hear your thoughts on peaking. I just checked and I have my peaking level set to middle (after some trials way back). Since you advocate low setting so strongly, I'll give it some more testing time.


oh!
Sensitivity set to 'low' at first might make look focusing more difficult and with enlargement the focus peaking at times pretty much may disappear, but it is the most precise.
I hope that you will find it helpful, curious about your opinion and experience!