MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

My hdr attempt
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

Having seen many amazing results here recently I was encouraged/inspired to take to HDR photography myself. Here are some of my favourites from the last couple of weeks. Most are with the Sigma 19mm/2.8 on NEX-5, so I'm posting in the AF section, only one or two are with my Minolta Rokkor MD 50mm/1.4. Some are true HDRs made from three bracketed shots (although only at +-0.7EV because my NEX-5 doesn't let me use a wider auto bracketing range and I'm too lazy to carry a tripod that would allow me to do better bracketing). The rest only have some pseudo HDR style processing made from one raw file developed with different exposure adjustments.

I'm pleased with some, not so much with others. I'm still learning and finding a good workflow. I've tried different techniques and different software:

- First I tried MacroFusion which is a frontend for enblend. It's a great piece of software for the times when you're after a more subtle, gentle approach to HDR. Requires some extra postprocessing to get the perfect result and in many cases manual blending of original exposures.

- Recently I've been playing with LumminanceHDR which is just amazing. I liked its previous name better, Qtpfsgui (easier to remember) but the newer versions are only getting better. It implements several tonemapping algorithms, some more some less useful. Right now my favourite approach is to make two tonemapped versions, one with Mantiuk '06 at gamma around 0.6 and other settings slightly boosted, and the other with Drago at more or less default settings. I then layer them together, Drago on top of Mantiuk with around 50% opacity, then one or two original exposures with low opacity applied locally. The individual layers receive some contrast boost as necessary. Finally I do some local dodging&burning and add a bit of saturation by applying a not too steep S curve on the a and b channels in LAB. This all done in the GIMP.

Here's a selection of what I managed so far:

1: Made from 3 bracketed shots with Macrofusion.


2: Only one raw file and not much processing, just some layer blending. The light was perfect.


3: Here the scene looked great but the light turned out to be horrible. Only one raw, Macrofusion. I wish I could be there during sunset.


4: Three raws, Macrofusion.


5: Same as #4.


6: Also three raws. The light was flat, didn't really require hdr processing.


7. Again three raws and Macrofusion.


8: Only one raw, not very happy with this one. It really is all about light.


9: Three raws, Macrofusion. I wish I used wider bracketing. This time I did have a tripod with me but didn't bother to set it up. Neutral


10: Three raws, LumminanceHDR. Went for a subtle apporach with blending differently tonemapped versions of the same hdr image. Quite pleased with the result.


11: Only one raw because of the movement. High ISO (800) has some noise and HDR processing exaggerates it a lot. I think I overprocessed this one.


12: Three raws at +-0.7EV, LumminanceHDR plus a lot of fiddling in GIMP. I like this one.


So what do you think? Is this going somewhere? Should I continue to experiment?


Reply

Great work!
All very "natural" not over-processed like most of the HDR images.


Reply

miran 氏の書き込み:
So what do you think? Is this going somewhere? Should I continue to experiment?


YES, you've made some great images here!

I've never seen hayracks like that before, looks very practical.


Reply

Great work.
I wouldn't say any of them is hdr at a first glance.
Then I see where the sun is and realize it wouldn't be possible with standard images.


Reply

Naaaaaaah , this is no HDR , it's like one would see the scene , where are those strong overprocessed colors and obviously manipulated look of the images ? Laughing
Excellent , congratulations !
You should write a tutorial here for this kind of work ! I'd like to learn to do this!


Reply

Thanks everyone. Smile

引用:
I've never seen hayracks like that before, looks very practical.

As far as I'm told this is mainly a Slovenian thing. There are a few different designs, each region has their own. Here's some different examples:







Smile

引用:
Naaaaaaah , this is no HDR , it's like one would see the scene , where are those strong overprocessed colors and obviously manipulated look of the images ?

I understand what you mean, but seriously, I think most people think HDR stands for overprocessed oversaturated cartoony images. When in fact the letters HDR mean High Dynamic Range. Meaning HDR photography is about photographing scenes with high dynamic range (deep shadows and bright highlights) onto low dynamic range photographic mediums without losing detail in any part. The way the human eye sees. That cartoony style should really be called something else, not HDR.

引用:
You should write a tutorial here for this kind of work ! I'd like to learn to do this!

I would but as I said, I'm still learning and tweaking the process so anything I write will be obsolete and outdated the next week when I learn about something else. Razz But yeah, I'll do that, if nothing else, at least to keep as a reference for myself. Smile


Reply

Anyway , I like your results .Seems a little complicated for those who don't play with Photoshop/gimp like a joke.
I tried on gimp using a tutorial but gave up.


Reply

It's not THAT complicated as long as you have a good understanding of what it is you're doing. I'll try to come up with a tutorial of some sort soon. Smile Although I'm not sure I'm in the position to actually write tutorials about this stuff yet. Wink


Reply

miran 氏の書き込み:
It's not THAT complicated as long as you have a good understanding of what it is you're doing. I'll try to come up with a tutorial of some sort soon. Smile Although I'm not sure I'm in the position to actually write tutorials about this stuff yet. Wink


Complicated or not, you've done a good job keeping everything natural. No ridiculous colours and no flatness of image. Well done!


Reply

Really like the results, especially the first batch (first 9). Your post processing and HDR works, and does not make it look unreal. I think Ian has also shown with some of his later attempts that if you handle it carefully it is possible to achieve a close to natural look.


Reply

#2, #3, #4 and #9 are my favourites, however all your photos are great.
Just like other guys said, it's the perfect use of HDR, not too much, absolutely spot on.

Mateusz


Reply

They are very nice, Miran. Your use of HDR is the way I prefer to use it, the way it is most useful.

I've only dabbled in HDR, but those I've done have been to reveal detail that mostly goes unseen.


Reply

HRD as it should be done, if one wants to look realistic, well dome #10 and #12 from the first set for me, i know exactly where you took #1 Smile.

Tomas


Reply

Thanks again, everyone. Smile

tomasg 氏の書き込み:
i know exactly where you took #1 Smile.

I seriously doubt that. Wink


Reply

miran 氏の書き込み:
Thanks again, everyone. Smile

tomasg 氏の書き込み:
i know exactly where you took #1 Smile.

I seriously doubt that. Wink


Road to Vanganel?


Reply

No.

All locations marked on a map: https://mapsengine.google.com/map/viewer?mid=znOvhneGtqWI.kk9odj3Il2Wc Wink


Reply

So many great images!! Congrats! Way to go!


Reply

miran 氏の書き込み:
No.

All locations marked on a map: https://mapsengine.google.com/map/viewer?mid=znOvhneGtqWI.kk9odj3Il2Wc Wink


I would have bet 1000,00 eur it was the road to Vanganel Smile so similar.

Tomas