MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

Which (old, cheap) DSLR for my m42 lenses?
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

Dear all,

I'm in need of a new DSLR body, and having a limited financial resources (100-150EUR), I need to stick to older models. My initial thoughts include Minolta 7D, Pentax K100D and Canon 20D. All these can be found at eBay within that price range. My main concern is shooting in low light and using with my m42 Zeiss collection, but given the price range, I think I could do worse than choosing one of these models. I have looked at the sensor scores, the three models are comparable; also, I know that Minolta 7D is known to have an excellent user interface.

What do you think? Maybe something else I should put on my list?

j.


Reply

If it's of any interest I have a Canon EOS 10D for sale with only 870 shutter actuations on ebay at the moment.

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/281119535624?ssPageName=STRK:MESELX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1555.l2649


Reply

The Sony a100 takes wonderful pictures in good light due to its weak AA-filter. It is cheap but it has its limitations of course. If you want to shoot in low light it's no worse than the KM 7D.

I had a 7D and loved it, especially the ergonomics.


Reply

For that kind of money you could also have a sony Nex, excellent noise at low level focus peaking and compatability with hundreds more lenses
Sony a700 is also an excellent camera have seen a few very cheap for what it is £200


Reply

january-w 氏の書き込み:
Dear all,

I'm in need of a new DSLR body, and having a limited financial resources (100-150EUR), I need to stick to older models. My initial thoughts include Minolta 7D, Pentax K100D and Canon 20D. All these can be found at eBay within that price range. My main concern is shooting in low light and using with my m42 Zeiss collection, but given the price range, I think I could do worse than choosing one of these models. I have looked at the sensor scores, the three models are comparable; also, I know that Minolta 7D is known to have an excellent user interface.

What do you think? Maybe something else I should put on my list?

j.


One thing that would make me choose the Minolta 7D, in addition to its great ergonomics, is its in-body "Anti-Shake" technology, giving you image stabilization no matter what lens you use. In low-light situations it's a great advantage.


Reply

Don't know about prices, but I'd second Pontus suggestion on a100, it's a lovely camera -an old one though- and it had IBIS.
Obviously, if you can get more recent ones like a nex, you'll find improvements in term of resolution and low light performance.


Reply

The Pentax K10 and K20 are excellent cameras that can be found cheaply, but in low light the K10 is a tripod camera as it doesn't like high ISO. But on a tripod at low ISO it's excellent.


Reply

I'm selling EOS 20D here: http://forum.mflenses.com/big-sale-lenses-cameras-acessoaries-t58748.html
It is very nice camera - apart from that i nave ruined the contacts for AF - so it works only with manual lenses now.
I believe they can be replaced but don't know it it's worth doing it.

Please let me know if you want me to show some samples taken with it.


Reply

Dear all,

many thanks for all the wonderful tips. There are two things that make me tend towards KM7D. First is in comparison to Sony a100 and Pentax: lack of pentaprism and a smaller viewfinder. I found it really hard to manually focus with a previously used Canon 300D and its tiny, dark viewfinder -- especially as I was spoiled by the great viewfinders on my film cameras. I have two medium range Minolta AF lenses stashed somewhere, but my main interest (and fun) is in using my old m42 lenses. Also, a100 is said to have a poorer performance at high ISO (http://snapsort.com/compare/Konica_Minolta_Dynax_7D-vs-Sony_Alpha_DSLR-A100/specs).

Second, and that puts me off a bit in case of the Canons, is the in-body image stabilization. I have never had any experience with that before, but I hear that this would give me an additional EV in bad light conditions. And some of my old lenses are quite dark (e.g. I have a 4/20 Flektogon and two 4/135 lenses - a Triotar & a Jupiter, both in a lovely silver aluminium look). Do you have experience with Sony's / KM's IBIS? Does that really help this much?

Kind regards, j.


Reply

Sony nex first choice for manual lenses or you may get an A200 for around your budget, there was one on ebay the other day with a bin price of £99, not sure if it's still available (uk Ebay) I tend to use my nex for the lighter lenses and the A77 for the others but to be honest I prefer the Nex.


Reply

january-w 氏の書き込み:
Do you have experience with Sony's / KM's IBIS? Does that really help this much?

You have to be careful with that. If you have a dumb adapter, then IBIS will likely do more harm than good. You need an adapter with a chip that tells the camera the focal length of the lens so it can calculate how much to compensate for the shaking. If the camera doesn't know the focal length, it assumes 50mm or something like that and if you're using a radically different lens (like a 20mm or a 135mm), IBIS needs to be turned off otherwise it will get it totally wrong and the photos will be even more blured than without any stabilization. Bottom line, if you want the benefit of IBIS, you need chipped adapters (more expensive).

Also as someone who went from A100 to NEX, I would very much recommend to skip any and all DSLRs with small optical viewfinders and go straight to something that has live view focusing with focus peaking (i.e. Sony NEX and SLT cameras). Because the OVFs in modern DSLRs can't even begin to compare with even the worst viewfinders in old SLRs unless you go for a FF model and exchange the stock focusing screen with one that's more suitable for manual focusing (split prism). But that's way above your budget. The best option I think would be a NEX camera. You should be able to get a used first or second generation model for around 100€ easily.


Reply

About antishaker on Pentax (K20 and I assume is the same on K10/100) the camera ask the focal length whenever you attach a MF lens


Reply

Think you're correct, on my Sony Alpha to use SSS lens must be chipped


Reply

I have had a few Sony cameras, I have had the A200 a great camera, (sold), 2x A700 fanatastic camera both still owned and the A55 the liveview is excellent for manaul lenses and i really like the A55 for the size.
With regards to adaptors i have had no issues.
Also be wary of the KM7D due to common FFB (first frame black) issue


Reply

miran 氏の書き込み:
You need an adapter with a chip that tells the camera the focal length of the lens so it can calculate how much to compensate for the shaking.


Yes, I know. That seems to be the problem with 7D.

引用:
Also as someone who went from A100 to NEX, I would very much recommend to skip any and all DSLRs with small optical viewfinders and go straight to something that has live view focusing with focus peaking (i.e. Sony NEX and SLT cameras).


Indeed, that is a reason why I picked 20D and 7D in my choices; both have a large, light viewfinder with pentaprism, and a split-screen viewfinder for the 7D apparently can be bought for as little as ~ EUR 20. However, I'm not sure of the quality of this chinese product. In any case, I have tried a 7D with the regular viewfinder, and while it was not as good as a split-prism, it was a tremendous improvement over the minuscule canon x00D / a100 / etc. viewfinders.

引用:
The best option I think would be a NEX camera. You should be able to get a used first or second generation model for around 100€ easily.


This sounds very tempting to say the least, a small camera has so many advantages, and the tilt screen makes me to think of my times with Start (http://silverlightalchemy.blogspot.de/2012/08/the-polish-start-twin-lens-reflex.html). May I step on your time with a few more questions?

* Most importantly -- do you need to navigate through the menus to change things like EV adjustment, ISO, aperture / time priority?
* Are there any short-cut buttons?
* How high with ISO can you go to get still high quality photographs -- ISO 800? higher?
* Do you have experience with m42 lenses / lense adapters? Are the adapters less of a nightmare than in case of the 7D? (e.g. for in focus display, do they require some special programming etc.)?

P.S. After reading this review (http://photo.tutsplus.com/articles/hardware/sony-nex-3-a-beautiful-design-but-how-does-it-stack-up/) I'm especially worried about the following:

引用:
However, unlike other hybrids, it’s not designed to tempt enthusiasts who’ve already got a D-SLR and want something smaller to carry around with them. On paper, the NEX does everything – and more – that an SLR or any other hybrid does, but in practice the everyday photographic controls you’ll want to use are just to difficult to get to. (...) Cons: (...) Tedious and time-consuming interface


Thank you in advance - j.


最終編集: january-w、水 6月 12, 2013 5:31 pm、計 1 回


Reply

january-w 氏の書き込み:


* Most importantly -- do you need to navigate through the menus to change things like EV adjustment, ISO, aperture / time priority?
* Are there any short-cut buttons?
* How high with ISO can you go to get still high quality photographs -- ISO 800? higher?
* Do you have experience with m42 lenses / lense adapters? Are the adapters less of a nightmare than in case of the 7D? (e.g. for in focus display, do they require some special programming etc.)?


Thank you in advance - j.


Referring to the Nex (5 in my case)
1/2. Nope there are 2 customizable buttons and to the main one can be assisgned 3 different parameters
3. Nex5 noise reduction in jpg isn't that good so i shoot in raw, in some case you can go up till 1600 ISO
4. Not at all. Easy and fast with the MF assistant (magnification 7x and 14x) and focus peaking


Reply

I tried a nex 5 for some days, and then bought a 5n, which i found sensibly better in high iso performance (and with full manual exposure control in video mode).
with my 5n, I go lightheartedly as high as iso 800 without any problems, iso 1600 is usable most of the times.
Setting the keys will allow you to easily access all the parameters without need to dig in the menu, and the combo magnification+focus peaking is a killer feature for focussing manual.
For me, nex5n handling is a little weird: I also have an slt-a55 which is similar in performance (nex5n is a bit better, actually), and i thend to prefer using the slt, which is however extremely compact.
But that's kind of subjective


Reply

And on 5n you have touch screen - which is very handy if you want to click on a particular part of the image which you want to see enlarged during manual focus.


Reply

january-w 氏の書き込み:

* Most importantly -- do you need to navigate through the menus to change things like EV adjustment, ISO, aperture / time priority?
* Are there any short-cut buttons?
* How high with ISO can you go to get still high quality photographs -- ISO 800? higher?
* Do you have experience with m42 lenses / lense adapters? Are the adapters less of a nightmare than in case of the 7D? (e.g. for in focus display, do they require some special programming etc.)?

* On most models some buttons are customizable. If you set them to perform the functions you use most often, you practically don't need the menus. On the other hand, when you do need to go through the menus, it's a big pain.

* Regarding ISO it all depends on the light and exposure. On my NEX-5 base ISO is 200 and if I get it wrong, it will have a huge amount of noise. With proper exposure you can get very decent results at ISO3200, printable to at least 30x45cm. I go up to ISO1600 without thinking twice and often use 3200. That's NEX-5, the newer models are supposedly even better.

* The NEX system is probably the best system for using adapted lenses. Anything fits, all kinds of adapters are available, nothing special is required, focus peaking works perfectly.


Reply

The Nex will give you superb image quality, but handling is really subjective. Even with the customisable buttons, the controls are still very small and hard to find sometimes. The body is tiny too, and I found handling with larger size lenses incredibly difficult. But no older DSLR will match a Nex for high ISO image quality.

As for image stabilisation, you must remember that it won't freeze the action...only allow slower shutter speeds with less camera shake. The a100 is terrible above ISO 400. The a200 and newer require a chip with the correct focal length programmed for effective stabilsation (the 5D, 7D, a100 and a700 don't need a chip, but will default to 50mm if no chip is present). The old Pentax cameras aren't much better above ISO 400 either.

If you want really good handling and a decent enough viewfinder with top LCD and easy to use controls, then I would go for a Canon EOS body. Personally, I preferred the larger screen of the 30D over the 20D, so I would recommend a 30D if you can stretch for one. The 10D has poor high ISO and a more difficult to use control system, but otherwise is solid.


Reply

Yeah, the NEX 5N is nice, but way off the limits, not my price range. Thanks anyways!


Reply

well if you have decided to take minolta 7D which is a great camera please do check how much more expensive sony a700 would be. It is the best camera I have ever owned really good ergonomics, much faster and accurate then minolta with much better noise control


Reply

nurkov 氏の書き込み:
well if you have decided to take minolta 7D which is a great camera please do check how much more expensive sony a700 would be. It is the best camera I have ever owned really good ergonomics, much faster and accurate then minolta with much better noise control


A100 costs more or less the same on eBay. However, um, how high you can go with ISO still having good quality? Some test results suggest that A100 performs worse than KM 7D above 400, but I don't know wheteher it is reliable. Also, what I like about the KM 7D is the large pentaprism viewfinder.

j.


Reply

With the A100 I was comfortable using up to ISO800 if I was careful. ISO1600 is for emergency use only. I double 7D is any better. You also have to take into account that the 7D has an older 6MP sensor and the A100 has 10MP. Many of those "tests" are based on comparing noise at the pixel level which is wrong.

About the large pentaprism viewfinder, even that will be not even close to a proper film SLR viewfinder for example.


Reply

I have to agree. I've had a KM5D, 7D, a700 and a900. Focussing with manual lenses is very hard with all of these cameras, especially on larger apertures where pinpoint accuracy is needed. Even the fantastic viewfinder of the a900 was not enough. I didn't have a split screen though, which would have helped.

In my opinion, for manual focus lenses, focus assistance is a must. So I shoot my manual focus lenses with the NEX system.