MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

NEX or DSLR for manual focus lenses?
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

I am a bit of a newcomer to this whole manual focus lens thing. I've dug up some old russian lenses i've had for over 10 years that were used on the film cameras and used them on a Canon XTi (EOS 400d) with m42/m39 adapters. I really enjoyed the pictures taken with them. My main "modern" camera is a Nikon D5100, which works for my Nikon lenses, but is not compatible with the old manual focus ones.

Right now the Nex5N body sells for $399 new, and a newer canon rebel can be had for about as much. I am considering now to sell the XTi while it is still worth something on ebay and get either a NEX or a newer Canon. What I dislike about the xti is the tiny optical viewfinder which makes getting good focus a bit hard. Are the NEX cameras a little better in this regard? How easy is it to use the display instead of the viewfinder to get good focus?


Reply

There is no generally considered correct answer to your question. Some users say they won't do without optical viewfinder, other say that a mirrorless allows for much easier manual focusing.
I am in the second camp, enlarged view + focus peaking on LCD and even better inside an EVF are great tools for manual focusing!
Many dSLR also offer enlarged view during live view, some newer models even focus peaking ( e.g. Pentax K-30 ) but of course this is only on the LCD and most practicable when on a tripod. Using liveview + enlarged view handheld a mirrorless has the advantage of the lighter body but more importantly is another thing altogether if using an EVF! I would my 5N not want to be without it. Besides I'd think that one rather needed a top level APS-C sensor dSLR, even a FF dSLR to have a viewfinder of comparable size.

NEX5N for 400usd for a top IQ performer for an APS-C camera is a great deal! If you can afford add the 250usd for it's EVF and you also have top manual focusing abilities


Reply

In my opinion you have only two options: either a full frame DSLR with a MF focusing screen installed (i.e. Canon 5D) or a NEX. Depends on what you prefer, OVF or live view focusing with focus peaking and magnified view on either rear LCD or EVF. Well, there's actually a third option - one of the newer Sony SLTs. They're the size and shape of a normal DSLR if that's what you want, but they have an EVF which is actually the same size as an OVF in a full frame DSLR and shows you the same image as the rear LCD. But one major advantage of the NEX over DSLR/SLT is that you can put more lenses on it because of the shorter flange distance.


Reply

miran 氏の書き込み:
But one major advantage of the NEX over DSLR/SLT is that you can put more lenses on it because of the shorter flange distance.


That is true.
On the other hand, however, you will not enjoy those lenses in the full, because with the crop format you will lose a significant portion of the image.
Whereas a full frame camera gives back the true experience of the manual lenses that you use on it.


Reply

The only FF DSLR I can afford now is the canon 5d classic used. Is that really a viable option these days or is it going to be rapidly devalued by the influx of the new lower cost FF cameras when they appear on used market? I am also not crazy about the size of the 5d, the rebel/Nikon d5100 is about the perfect size for me.

The real choice is between a newer rebel or the nex... the shorter flange distance is intriguing. Are there any drawbacks associated with it though? Would the lens act exactly the same on a camera with a shorter flange distance?


Reply

zenit55 氏の書き込み:
Is that really a viable option these days or is it going to be rapidly devalued


It is already devalued, I don't think it can be more devalued than now, compared to APS-C cameras the old 5D has the strong point of the full frame format,
full frame digital cameras retain an acceptable used value even after years rightly because they're full frame. APS-C cameras get devalued much faster.
For instance, after Sony will release a full frame Nex, all the current APS-C Nexes will lose value very rapidly (much faster and more drastically than full frame cameras).


Reply

I've been without a DSLR for over 6 months now, my Pentax K10 died. So I got a NEX5, and I have to say that although I'm sure I will get another DSLR, I'm not frantically searching for one.
I use old MF lenses almost exclusively, and I honestly think I'm getting a better hit rate of sharp and well exposed shots from the NEX. There's actually very little I miss from the DSLR.

I think my next DSLR will be full frame, so I'm kinda waiting for the next generation of FF cameras from the major manufacturers to drive the price of the current generation down a bit. My theory might not work, Rolling Eyes but I'm not desperate while I've got the NEX.


Reply

There are "only" two reasons why you could choose a dslr over a nex (speaking of manual lenses usage) in my opinion.

First is that you're going to buy a FF dslr: this makes comparisons impossible, it's just too different. For someone it just doesn't matter, for others it's something necessary. But if you want your lens to be at their right angle of view, you simply can't with a nex.

Other is handling: I love my nex 5n, it's tiny, light, beautiful, and can mount every lens I can think of, but in the end I like shooting with my slt (similar sensor, EVF) much better. And I even get a slightly higher percentage of good shots.

Apart from those (i.e. you don't mind about crop factor so much and you feel comfortable handling a nex), it's a no-brainer, especially considering how little a new nex5 costs nowadays.


Reply

Several very good answers already!

Answer those questions for yourself...


1. Do you want a compact and light camera? >> NEX
2. Do you want an optical viewfinder? >> DSLR
3. Do you want a camera that "feels" like a traditional SLR? >> DSLR
4. Do you want to adapt Konica, Minolta or rangefinder lenses? >> NEX
5. Do you want a wide variety of AF lenses? >> DSLR (but NEX is catching up) Wink
6. Do you want "fullframe"? >> DSLR (but a fullframe one) (We will have to wait for a fullframe-NEX for a while still...)

If you have answered all questions with "yes", you need a fullframe DSLR AND an NEX. Wink


最終編集: LucisPictor、水 9月 26, 2012 6:22 pm、計 1 回


Reply

LucisPictor 氏の書き込み:
Have you answered all questions with "yes", you need a fullframe DSLR AND an NEX. Wink


Sometimes we just forget about the easiest and most logical solution Very Happy


Reply

zenit55 氏の書き込み:
..
The real choice is between a newer rebel or the nex... the shorter flange distance is intriguing. Are there any drawbacks associated with it though? Would the lens act exactly the same on a camera with a shorter flange distance?

Adapters for SLR lenses are empty tubes with the respective mounts to each side which introduce the correct distance between lens and sensor. I have not heard of and can't think of any influence short register distance + adapter could have on the performance of the lens.
Very wide lenses with very short register distance, speak rangefinder M and L39 wide angle lenses, have well documented corner issues, less on NEX5N than on NEX7, but there are none with SLR lenses.
btw. NEX cameras expose any lens very well in A and S mode, optionally with auto ISO. In M mode live histogram guides settings for desired exposure


Reply

Or you can wait a few months for a fullframe NEX. Smile


Reply

miran 氏の書き込み:
Or you can wait a few months for a fullframe NEX. Smile

A few "months"? A few "years" probably. Wink


Reply

Uhm, no? The VG900 is available right now. In case you don't know, that's basically a fullframe NEX in the shape of a camcorder. Has the same sensor as A99 and Nikon D600 and the same mount as all other NEX cameras. It's just a matter of time when they'll release a proper photo camera with the same sensor.


Reply

Well, the fact that all the technology is ready doesn't mean that they will release it.

How much will it have to cost? I think it should cost less than a99, and in that case, will it steal buyers from a99?
I mean, marketing logics often are different from common sense: i hope they will release it, but all the clues (FF compact, FF E mount camcorder) that make me hope, don't mean it will happen soon.
They don't meant it won't, either, it was just to say.


Reply

for me the main appeal of the NEX right now is the price. I can sell the outdated XTi for about 200 and get the NEX for minimal $$. So waiting for FF and paying a whole lot more doesn't make much sense to me. I bet if they did come out with the FF NEX, it would cost more than the NEX7, which is already out of my price range (at that price point I might as well get a refurbished Canon 5D markII).

The decision right now really is between a Canon 550D/600D or a NEX5N. After reading all this I am leaning towards a NEX, because another compact DSLR would be a bit redundant with my Nikon D5100.


Reply

I can't really see much advancement in DSLR's in the near future, and losing the mechanical bits like the mirror just make a lighter, and potentially faster, camera.
And that is why I agree that Sony is unlikely to release a FF NEX until the A99 has at least peaked in its sales.


Reply

No doubt for me : NEX is the way to go . You can mount about any lens on it and the focusing system is very good , even for those with eye disturbances.
As for the FF DSLR there still is another solution : a 35mm film body .that's my FF for now and , it seems for a long time . the FF DSLR prices ar much too high . Well processed and well scanned the film can offer very good IQ .I get a bit less 12MP file from my Minolta Dimage III scanner (paid 85 Euro) . The IV gives about 15mp fom a 35mm frame if I corectly remember .
You can get more bodies with different mounts and get them cheap (as I do) for your lenses .Of course , there are costly ones if you use Contax or Leica lenses.
You won't have the advantages of the DSLR ( instant check up and corecting instant results available ) but I consider a fair trade.And fun .


Reply

miran 氏の書き込み:
Uhm, no? The VG900 is available right now. In case you don't know, that's basically a fullframe NEX in the shape of a camcorder. Has the same sensor as A99 and Nikon D600 and the same mount as all other NEX cameras. It's just a matter of time when they'll release a proper photo camera with the same sensor.


I do know about that cam. Trust me.

But at the SONY booth at the Photokina, a lady from Sony told me that they do not have precise plans to market a fullframe-NEX at the moment.
They would need appropriate (non-APS) lenses first, she said.

Actually, I do not believe Sony a lot. If they tell us that a NEX-9 will be available in spring 2013, I expect it for Xmas 2013!

They promised a firmware-update for the NEX-7 in April 2012 and we are still waiting...


Reply

yinyangbt 氏の書き込み:
No doubt for me : NEX is the way to go . You can mount about any lens on it and the focusing system is very good , even for those with eye disturbances.
As for the FF DSLR there still is another solution : a 35mm film body .that's my FF for now and , it seems for a long time . the FF DSLR prices ar much too high . Well processed and well scanned the film can offer very good IQ .I get a bit less 12MP file from my Minolta Dimage III scanner (paid 85 Euro) . The IV gives about 15mp fom a 35mm frame if I corectly remember .
You can get more bodies with different mounts and get them cheap (as I do) for your lenses .Of course , there are costly ones if you use Contax or Leica lenses.
You won't have the advantages of the DSLR ( instant check up and corecting instant results available ) but I consider a fair trade.And fun .


+1 I have two NEX-3 bodies, one samsung NX100 and one Panasonic G1, I can shoot parallel with many lenses all cheap bodies and serve me well.


Reply

I think the only real reason to buy a DSLR is auto-focus.

Sensor size is moderately important still - which is why I really enjoy the NEX 5N. If it shot cleaner ISO past 1600 (ie 3200 and 6400) it'd be a perfect camera. I wouldn't mind an optical viewfinder - but I find that composing with the LCD generally makes my images better.


Reply

There is no perfect camera. And there will never be a perfect camera.

But imo +1 for NEX 5N (or NEX-6 or 3/5/3C for low budet) - it's a very good start, especially with if you find one with an electronic viewfinder.

@plasticmotif
At ISO3200 the NEX-5N is actually one of the very best cameras in the APS-C league
Only some of the latest and some FF cameras are able to beat the NEX-5N high iso


Reply

I tried manual lens with both DSLR and the Nex system and the Nex wins hand down with peak focus. I started out with the Nex 3 and just got a Nex 5N because price is just too good at $399. Very Happy


Reply

There is one other thing to consider.....

You can get adapters with focus confirm chip for the Canon DSLRs interfaced with MF lenses. However, unlike the older focus confirm chip which was often a bit out regarding focus, you can get the newer type which has adjustable maximum aperture and front/back focus. that means you can tune it for exact focus for a particular lens(es).

If you're looking for this type, it is described as having the new "EMF" programmable AF chip.

You can use Nikon/Nikkor, Olympus OM, Pentax K and M42 lenses with Canon DLSRs, able to focus to infinity.


Reply

I bought a new Nikon D3200 recently. I'm still learning but since buying an old MF lens I have noticed that it's easier to focus than AF on my Nikon with a brand new 35mm Nikkor prime.

Maybe there's a problem with the calibration or maybe it's my technique. I don't know.

Having said all that the NEX is what I will buy very soon. Focus peaking and using liveview zoomed to max is what I think is best way to produce quality shots. I'll keep my Nikon but I suspect it will not get used very often.

I'll just get the 3N for now as I know there will be major upgrades in 2014.