MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

3 of my favourites, but I can handle the criticism.....
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

1.
Dissolution by skida, on Flickr


Unedited Version of "Dissolution" by skida, on Flickr

2.
Unexplained Building by skida, on Flickr

3.
Peace at Derwent Water by skida, on Flickr

All are on film as I don't have a manual focus digital camera.


最終編集: skida、月 5月 07, 2012 5:30 pm、計 2 回


Reply

#1 to me perfect, sharp , 3D , texture everything.
#2 don't get it why in your favorite three, please explain it!
#3 classic lake picture well done!


Reply

I agree with Attila on 1 and 3, but 2, I like it, composition is nice but it is the quality of the light that makes it for me.

1 is wonderful, congrats.


Reply

Agree for the most part, except
#1 sharpening? Looks a little overdone, possibly by some auto process
#2 may have benefited from a filter to reduce the light in the top half of the shot



patrickh


Reply

Well I'm not an expert on composition and can only judge on what I like/dislike:-

1, VG but the sky above the arch is annoying and I would crop it out or better add a few stones with photoshop like the right side (no one would spot it Wink )
2. Don't get it, no link to the subjects Confused
3. No sparkle or life probably wrong time of the day.

Sorry.


Reply

1. The bit of missing ruin which is letting the sky show at the top left is a minor irritation for me. I tried cropping but it put the point of the arch too close to the edge and I hated it. I thought about cloning, but just couldn't bring myself to compromising integrity. I decided I like the rest of the photo too much to let it bother me.

2. It may be the memory of the day and that the photo worked just the way I wanted it to, rather than great artistic merit that made me choose it as a favourite.

3. Again, it may be a personal thing, but the photo conveyed the feeling I experienced at that location and time of day (plus, just 10 minutes earlier, I had found a Zuiko 1.8/50 in great condition at a charity shop and it was wrapped up in my pocket when I took this shot).

Thanks for the critiques so far: All valid and fair.


最終編集: skida、月 5月 07, 2012 12:23 am、計 1 回


Reply

In #2 what are those buildings?


Reply

Excalibur 氏の書き込み:
In #2 what are those buildings?


Read the title! Laughing

I have been frustrated in my research by not finding an answer I am 100% confident in, but old maps show "Air Shaft" at roughly this location in the 40s/50s. It is roughly central to 3 old coal mines and I wonder if it housed a big ventilation fan/engine. The walls look very thick and solid and my initial thought was a military purpose, but Blyth had a coastal battery and an anti aircraft battery from the wars and both are shown on all the old maps and current ones.


Reply

skida 氏の書き込み:
Excalibur 氏の書き込み:
In #2 what are those buildings?


Read the title! Laughing

I have been frustrated in my research by not finding an answer I am 100% confident in, but old maps show "Air Shaft" at roughly this location in the 40s/50s. It is roughly central to 3 old coal mines and I wonder if it housed a big ventilation fan/engine. The walls look very thick and solid and my initial thought was a military purpose, but Blyth had a coastal battery and an anti aircraft battery from the wars and both are shown on all the old maps and current ones.


Ah Your next mission if you choose to accept is:- to get on the roof or inside the buildings and take some close up shots. Wink


Reply

Excalibur 氏の書き込み:
skida 氏の書き込み:
Excalibur 氏の書き込み:
In #2 what are those buildings?


old maps show "Air Shaft" at roughly this location in the 40s/50s.


Ah Your next mission if you choose to accept is:- to get on the roof or inside the buildings and take some close up shots. Wink


"...and he was never seen again....."


Reply

The first shot is just outstanding to me ! I would love to see an actual print of this !

The second shot has some mystery to it but the light exceeded color films abilities in this one for me.

The third is a nice landscape ! It has nice foreground interest and is just a lovely scene. I think the film captured the light really well for such demanding conditions. I also agree a filter may have helped but with the general shape of the highlights it may have been tough to use without intruding onto the scene ? I'm not always very good with nd grads myself.

#1 is a corker for me !


Reply

I've seen buildings exactly the same as those mysteries one before, on old airfields at Cark, Walney and Haverigg.

They are either air-raid shelters or munitions stores, they would have been embanked with earth.


Reply

#1: Gave me an immediate "back-to-Armenia" feeling Smile Lots of convents in ruins there.
The gate is offering the viewer the opportunity to enter the ruin and to engage in your photo. Nicely done.
I would cut off a small section at the upper side, just enough to remove the hole in the wall that now allows you to see the sky. It draws away the eye from the center of attention after some time, so better cut it.
The image seems to contain many artefacts: scanning, JPEG artefacts... ?


Reply

fotomachi 氏の書き込み:
The image seems to contain many artefacts: scanning, JPEG artefacts... ?


I have added the original lab scan version for comparison. I hope you will agree that my editing was quite subtle and an improvement.


Reply

They are all good and well composed in my opinion.
In #1 I think I prefer the unedited version.
I would have exposed #1 and #2 half a stop darker.


Reply

Orio 氏の書き込み:
I would have exposed #1 and #2 half a stop darker.


I know you would have. Laughing