MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

Fuji X100 and Pentax 645 - Fun Comparison
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

Here are two similar (sort of) shots of the same plant group and foliage
area in the Bloedel Reserve.

Different light, different comps.. Remember that this is just for fun,
we don't want any "wars" here about digital versus film. Yes,
I'm comparing in a way, but just for fun comparisons. Smile

Very low light in this area, as it was surrounded by Hemlock trees. I
had to go to ISO1600 because it was just too dark to handhold at a
lower ISO.

I will get back to this area, and set up the tripod next time for two exact
same compositions. These images are just for looking at different
renderings. Just fooling around!

Both straight from the camera. Well....I guess the Pentax image is
actually straight from the camera + scanner, but you know what I'm
saying. Laughing

In a very low-level way, both images are clear and clean. The X100
image looks more "delicate" in colors. The Pentax image looks
more "dense" in colors. At least to me.


Fuji X100
ISO1600
f:3.5 1/70 sec








Pentax 645
Pentax-A 55/2.8
f:4 1/4 sec
Velvia 100F



Reply

To me definitely Pentax + Velvia what I like better.


Reply

Attila 氏の書き込み:
To me definitely Pentax + Velvia what I like better.


Yeah, the richness is definitely there, Attila.

One nice realization to me, is that I can shoot all day at ISO1600 with
the X100, and not feel like I'm compromising clarity all that much
from ISO200 or ISO100.

As I indicated above, next weekend I'll go back (if the flowers are still
fresh) and set up the tripod to take very similar images in similar
light conditions and all that. That would be a fun thing to look at. Very Happy


Reply

Rats. One thing I forgot was to set the X100 to "Velvia". This was at the
"Normal" setting. Oh well...next time.


Reply

I too would score the Pentax 645 higher. But mostly because the flowers and leaves are closer to the camera, thus more detail is visible. I thought the Fuji handled the greens well. Did you have it set to emulate Velvia also with these shots?

I'm looking forward to A-B comparisons with identical subjects. Being a 645 shooter myself (although it's a Bronica ETR-Si, and not a Pentax), I'm more than just a bit curious about your results.


Reply

I feel plastic on every image what I saw from Fuji Embarassed perhaps just my mind Laughing


Reply

Attila 氏の書き込み:
I feel plastic on every image what I saw from Fuji Embarassed perhaps just my mind Laughing


... that includes also the Velvia 100F ... ? Wink

greets leo


Reply

Certainly Fuj here is FX100


Reply

Both look quite acceptable at this size and light condition.
The real deal with the Fuji will be when you can process the RAW files in LR3 or Aperture3.
Until then it's not fair to judge IMO.


Reply

F16SUNSHINE 氏の書き込み:
Both look quite acceptable at this size and light condition.
The real deal with the Fuji will be when you can process the RAW files in LR3 or Aperture3.
Until then it's not fair to judge IMO.


I agree. This was not to judge on any sort of official level, that's for sure.

I don't have LR or Aperture, but I must assume a convervison will
be available soon in Adobe Photoshop?

Is LR3 or Aperture3 a better way to go?

Oh Andy...you have a PM or two. Very Happy

Larry


Reply

leo_b 氏の書き込み:
Attila 氏の書き込み:
I feel plastic on every image what I saw from Fuji Embarassed perhaps just my mind Laughing


... that includes also the Velvia 100F ... ? Wink

greets leo


It took me a while leo...but I finally understand the joke! Very Happy Forgive
me, I'm very slow at times.


Reply

Attila 氏の書き込み:
I feel plastic on every image what I saw from Fuji Embarassed perhaps just my mind Laughing


There IS a difference indeed. But of COURSE! It's like comparing a Bentley
to a Morris Mini, right? Laughing One is a big old cruiser and the other is a
squirrely little compact. Both have their own virtues and quirks.

That said, I don't think you are TOO far out of your mind. Laughing


Reply

Well, no wonder you're so happy Larry, if I read the current DxO comparative test, where the X100 sensor outperforms every other 4/3 sensor and also scores very well against the APS-C sensor class, only outperformed by the Nikon D7000!!

http://front1.dxomark.com/index.php/News/DxOMark-news/Fuji-X100-sensor-measured-on-DxOMark.com


Reply

Laurence 氏の書き込み:

I don't have LR or Aperture, but I must assume a convervison will
be available soon in Adobe Photoshop?


One would hope, if this camera really becomes popular. I've only used PS's raw converter sparingly and LR's even less, and I don't see them to be an advantage over Canon's Digital Photo Professional. How is the conversion software that came with your X100? If it seems to do a good job, you may not need anything else.


Reply

kds315* 氏の書き込み:
Well, no wonder you're so happy Larry, if I read the current DxO comparative test, where the X100 sensor outperforms every other 4/3 sensor and also scores very well against the APS-C sensor class, only outperformed by the Nikon D7000!!

http://front1.dxomark.com/index.php/News/DxOMark-news/Fuji-X100-sensor-measured-on-DxOMark.com


great to know that Fuji now produces a APS-C sensor which is up to the now very best, the Sony sensor used in Nikon D7000, Pentax K-5 and Sony cameras, good news for Nikon and Pentax to probably again have an alternative to Sony for a sensor supplier.

Would love to try it out this unique camera, and if only for experiencing it's viewfinder!


Reply

Velvia OK!


Reply

I like both. Very hard to pick a winner


Reply

Oddly both the modern Mini and the current Bentley are both made by... Volkswagon Smile

I am still pondering the irony of Ricoh, who used to make Pentax wannabees and now own the company!

Doug



Laurence 氏の書き込み:
Attila 氏の書き込み:
I feel plastic on every image what I saw from Fuji Embarassed perhaps just my mind Laughing


There IS a difference indeed. But of COURSE! It's like comparing a Bentley
to a Morris Mini, right? Laughing One is a big old cruiser and the other is a
squirrely little compact. Both have their own virtues and quirks.

That said, I don't think you are TOO far out of your mind. Laughing