MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

24/f2 Zeiss (ZA)
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

The lens is finally out - Distagon 24mm f2 for Minolta/Sony A mount. By the way, this is an AF lens. Here are some info:

Focal Length: 24mm
Max Aperture: F2
Lens Construction: 9 elements/7 groups
2 ED glass elements
2 aspherical glass elements

Minimum focus: 0.19m
Maximum Magnification: 0.29x
Filter Thread: 72mm
Weight: 555g
Dimension: 78mm diameter x 76mm length
Street price: € 1250 (EU); £1100 (UK)

Further details:
Press Release: http://www.dpreview.com/news/1007/10072705sonyalpha24mm35mm85mm.asp#press
Preview: http://www.dpreview.com/previews/sony_24_2_m15/


Reply

Any idea if the new ZA share any similarity with any of the other 25mm distagon?


Reply

DPreview's ZA 24/2's sample shots are underwhelming to me, the most of
samples are not sharp. And similar to Distagon 25/2.8 ZF/ZE vine shot
has soft corners, for example 25/2.8ZF shot @F11! (see the corners)>

I guess Sony's new 24/2 might have a strong curvature too in a close range.

The both 25/2.8 ZF and ZA 24/2 have very short MFDs under 0.2m, so
the new optical design could be very similar, that is what I suspect.

Flower shot example has good resolution to the corners, but close inspection tells me
it was shot by A700, which is not FF camera. Some examples are shot by this A700.


Reply

Um... what's the problem with Zeiss and 24-25mm? They make excellent 21 and 28... Also, I wonder whether Zeiss or Sony designed the 24/2...


Reply

my_photography 氏の書き込み:
Any idea if the new ZA share any similarity with any of the other 25mm distagon?


According to your 2nd link it has a supersonic motor and focuses by moving the rear group. I think that this makes if different from the ZF 2.8/25 Distagon, for example.


Reply

sichko 氏の書き込み:
my_photography 氏の書き込み:
Any idea if the new ZA share any similarity with any of the other 25mm distagon?


According to your 2nd link it has a supersonic motor and focuses by moving the rear group. I think that this makes if different from the ZF 2.8/25 Distagon, for example.


Other than the fact that it is AF, this case using supersonic motor (SSM - Sony/Minolta technology), I wonder if they are using the same glass formula etc. like the other 25mm Distagons - current or old.


最終編集: my_photography、木 7月 29, 2010 1:58 am、計 1 回


Reply

Sony's lens has one less group and element, but it has two aspherical
elements and 2 ED glasses. They cannot be the same as Zeiss 25/2.8 Zx,
but I still suspect Sony's is a derivative of Zeiss original Distagon design.

This is my wild guess....


Reply

I obviously can not speak about the Sony lens, and neither can I about the Z incarnation of the Distagon 25, but I know well the Contax version of the Distagon 25, having used it in many occasions, and I can tell for sure (and can prove) that I never got from it such pityful corners as in the image posted above.


Reply

Orio 氏の書き込み:
I obviously can not speak about the Sony lens, and neither can I about the Z incarnation of the Distagon 25, but I know well the Contax version of the Distagon 25, having used it in many occasions, and I can tell for sure (and can prove) that I never got from it such pityful corners as in the image posted above.

+1


Reply

koji 氏の書き込み:
DPreview's ZA 24/2's sample shots are underwhelming to me, the most of
samples are not sharp. And similar to Distagon 25/2.8 ZF/ZE vine shot
has soft corners, for example 25/2.8ZF shot @F11! (see the corners)>

I guess Sony's new 24/2 might have a strong curvature too in a close range.

The both 25/2.8 ZF and ZA 24/2 have very short MFDs under 0.2m, so
the new optical design could be very similar, that is what I suspect.

Flower shot example has good resolution to the corners, but close inspection tells me
it was shot by A700, which is not FF camera. Some examples are shot by this A700.


I do not see this image in the DP review. Also the title of this image includes '5D' - obviously not a Sony model, if indicative of a body.

Of the images on display at DP review, none showed as poorly as this.

(edit - I see now you are referencing the Z25)

I should add, with the close focus distance of the Z 25/2.8, the front element can literally be an inch from the subject. I assumed that the wide angle and close focus were very hard to keep the edges in focus for with the subject being so far from flat. The Contax 25 could not focus at this MFD so cannot be properly judged against the Z in close in circumstances. In my use, away from MFD, vignette was still obvious at wider apertures, but corner weakness was no where near as bad as at MFD and neither vignette nor corner sharpness were an issue by f11. As a negative, the ZK model I had was not properly corrected for infinity out of the box and needed to be sent back. When correctly adjusted, the ZK 25 was on par with my CV Voigtlanders for critical sharpness and color and completed that line-up as the close focusing wide for me.

Speculatively, I'd suggest that there will be more differences than similarities in the design of this 24 and the Z 25. Much like the 85 Planar in ZA was in fact an amalgamation of the Minolta 85/1.4 and of Zeiss engineering. It seems that the ZA's are designed by Zeiss to meet Sony's demands and to date, none are rehashed designs from Zeiss old bag of tricks, for better or worse.


K.


Reply

I just downloaded one of the sample images at dpreview.
It is the 4th one (DSC00139). It shows foliage, and is taken at least 1m away from the subject.

Well, the corners are awful. This is not a case of being OOF. The light falloff
at the corners of this lens has to be very significant. My Canon 17-40 did a much better job.

Also the fact that this an AF lens raises questions about who did what.
I suspect Zeiss just sold its brand name to Sony for some cash (this is a pity).
In Zeiss they have resisted AF in numerous occasions.
Why would they do it now and only in the ZA line?
My recently purchased 2/35 ZE and 2/100 ZE look very different to this lens.


Reply

nkanellopoulos 氏の書き込み:

Also the fact that this an AF lens raises questions about who did what.
I suspect Zeiss just sold its brand name to Sony for some cash (this is a pity).


There are a lot of speculation even among Sony users. Here is what Zeiss put in its FAQ site.
(Source from: http://www.zeiss.com/c12567a8003b58b9/Contents-Frame/c7fb960ed6f52805c125711e004ad17c)

3. Why are ZEISS lenses for Sony cameras produced in Japan?

Sony produces digital cameras of different types in extremely high numbers in several factories in Japan. The lenses for these cameras have to come from lens factories near the Sony camera manufacturing facilities to ensure reliable deliveries and minimize the economic risk of interrupted supplies.

ZEISS lenses for Sony digital cameras are developed by lens designers at the Carl Zeiss plant in Oberkochen, Germany. This includes all required quality assurance measures (test methods, test criteria, test devices, test procedures, lens performance target values, etc.) The lenses are then made in a lens production facility jointly chosen by Sony and Carl Zeiss. Quality assurance specialists from the Carl Zeiss plant in Oberkochen implement the ZEISS quality assurance system in the chosen facility. Many ZEISS optic measuring systems are installed. Carl Zeiss audits the lens production areas on a regular basis.

All these measures ensure that ZEISS lenses in Sony digital cameras meet the expectations demanding users associate with ZEISS lenses.


引用:
Why would they do it now and only in the ZA line?

As for why there are only AF Zeiss for Sony A mount, there is a speculations saying that Sony pay quite a substantial amount to make sure this AF is make exclusive for Sony A mount lens only. Unfortunately both Zeiss and Sony are silent on this as far as I know.


Reply

Saw this through other site:

http://artaphot.ch/lens-comparisons/305-a900-zeiss-za-224mm-16-35mm-24-70mm-minaf-2824mm-3517-35mm-g

So what's up with Sony and dpreview? Did they hand pick the worse sample for dpreview to preview? First it was the E 16/2.8, now 24/2. Laughing


Reply

my_photography 氏の書き込み:
Any idea if the new ZA share any similarity with any of the other 25mm distagon?

No. Sony "Zeiss" lenses have nothing in common with real Zeiss lenses, just the logo. It's like Panasonic "Leica" lenses or Samsung "Schneider" lenses. These giants just pay for famous logos to make their lenses more competitive in customers' eyes. I know that Leica has some basic requiremens which must be met to allow Panasonic use their brand, but I have no idea about Sony/Zeiss and Samsung/Schneider.

Anyway, the first line of Sony/Zeiss lenses were in fact enhanced Minolta designs (I wrote more detailed explanation here - see the second post), so I believe that the entire Sony/Zeiss product line is designed by old Minolta team.


Reply

The review is out on dpreview:

http://dpreview.com/lensreviews/sony_24_2_m15/

Is the flaring surprising for a T*???


Reply

no-X 氏の書き込み:

No. Sony "Zeiss" lenses have nothing in common with real Zeiss lenses, just the logo.


Then why does the Carl Zeiss website say:

引用:

ZEISS lenses for Sony digital cameras are developed by lens designers at the Carl Zeiss plant in Oberkochen, Germany.


Reply

no-X 氏の書き込み:
Sony "Zeiss" lenses have nothing in common with real Zeiss lenses, just the logo.

Sorry, incorrect. Have you used ZA lenses?

Someone from the FM forum asked Zeiss about the differences between the ZS and ZA line, and this is what they replied:

引用:
The ZA line is the result of close cooperation with Sony and is optimized to meet the requirements of the target groups addressed by Sony's products. Therefore, it is possible for two similar focal length types to have different designs and deliver different results. What they all have in common is the proven Carl Zeiss quality and the company’s aspiration to ensure the best imaging results in any situation.


You can make of this what you will, but I think it should be obvious that ZA lenses have a LOT more input from Zeiss than just their brand name and badge...

In the thread linked to above it's speculated that the ZA lenses are different from the other Z* lenses in order to make their rendering match with the rest of the Sony lens line which consists mostly of Minolta designs. This sounds sensible to me, and the words "requirements of the target groups" from the Zeiss representative seem to point exactly to this.


Reply

My understanding with some of these Zeiss branded lenses is that there are a series of specs that the lenses need to conform to, and as long as they do, Zeiss will give, what might be called, a "stamp of approval". My pet theory is that, while that should, in theory, guarantee a certain degree of quality, depending on how much money is involved, Zeiss might be inclined to... look the other way on occasions Smile