MFlenses - デジタル時代の新しさ
MFLenses 2026

マニュアルフォーカスレンズフォーラム

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。

修理ノート、実際のテスト写真、画像豊富な詳細アーカイブスレッドから、ヴィンテージレンズの世界を探検してください。
スポットライト

フォーラムトップページのおすすめパートナー掲載。

Canon EOS 5D Mk II or 1D Mk III
前のトピックへ :: 次のトピックへ  


Reply

If you had the choice between those 2 cameras for the same price (2300 to 2500 €), which would you choose ?

5D Mk II = 21 MPixels, FF.
1D Mk III = 10 Mpixels, x1.3

Which one would better fit old MF lenses and be the best to face future ? Smile


Reply

Pixel count is not important, but always choose full frame to fully enjoy manual focus lenses.


Reply

Olivier 氏の書き込み:
If you had the choice between those 2 cameras for the same price (2300 to 2500 €), which would you choose ?

5D Mk II = 21 MPixels, FF.
1D Mk III = 10 Mpixels, x1.3

Which one would better fit old MF lenses and be the best to face future ? Smile


Hi Olivier,

good question. There are hundret of threads to dicuss this issue.

There are advantages and disadvantges at both cams. If you will use the cam with older lenses (without AF) I would prefer the 5D, because the 1DMkIII is mainly designed for reporter, sport etc.

Ok, you can shot up to 10 pics (JPG) with the 1DMkIII, but is this neccessary with MF lenses ?

The 1DMkIII has also problems with the AF (if you plan to buy also AF lenses). The 5D is the more modern cam with good live view and a very good LCD (approx. 920.000 px). That helps a lot. Furthermore it is FF and the focal lenght of the lens is that for what it was designed. Maybe that you need "better" lenses as with a crop cam.

And at least, for 2.300 € you will get a new and actual 5D, for 2.500 € you will get a (new or used ?) 1DMKII and the successors is waiting in front of the door. And what is with the brand new 7D, you will get for approx. 1700,00 € but with crop 1.6. Also the latest technology in it.

Anyway, my vote : 5DMkII

Have a nice weekend.


Reply

Go for the 1D if you really need the pro body or if you want to use lenses that do not work with a 5D.

For all the other reasons, go for the 5D MkII. Wink


Reply

Olivier,

I have forgotten an important point. 5DmII has much better iso performance.


Reply

So, 5D MkII is the better one.
I saw a demonstration 1D Mk IIII for less than the D Mk II and that made me wonder. So, I asked for your opinion.
I will not change my 40D soon but next will be the 5D Mk II.
Thanks to all.


Orio, I undertand very well what you mean by fully enjoy lenses with FF since I received a Zenitar 2.8/17 fisheye. Results are disapointing on a x1.6. In fact, I have a very good and fast wide lens that I need to correct afterwards, but my daughter is sad because she awaited that lens to make magic ball effects with it. I think I'll have to buy a 0.25x fisheye addon for her...
Wink


Reply

Hi Olivier ---

I would recommend this:

1Ds Mark (no I, II or III)

click on this link:

http://www.imaging-resource.com/PRODS/EOS1DS/E1DSA.HTM

BENEFITS of EOS 1Ds -- (mind the 's' in the name, when finding out on ebay) Smile :

1 - it's FF
2 - 11 Mpx is enough
3 - you don't have to shave the mirror .. PLENTY MF LENSES MAY BE USED WITH NO PROBLEM. it's further behind than the mirror of 5D
4 - You may get it up to 800 GBP on ebay, if you're lucky..


This was an option I also had been considering before bought 5D MarkII for long time ..

tf


Reply

trifox 氏の書き込み:
Hi Olivier ---

I would recommend this:

1Ds Mark (no I, II or III)

click on this link:

http://www.imaging-resource.com/PRODS/EOS1DS/E1DSA.HTM

BENEFITS of EOS 1Ds -- (mind the 's' in the name, when finding out on ebay) Smile :

1 - it's FF
2 - 11 Mpx is enough
3 - you don't have to shave the mirror .. PLENTY MF LENSES MAY BE USED WITH NO PROBLEM. it's further behind than the mirror of 5D
4 - You may get it up to 800 GBP on ebay, if you're lucky..


This was an option I also had been considering before bought 5D MarkII for long time ..

tf


Thank you Trifox.


Reply

trifox 氏の書き込み:
Hi Olivier ---

I would recommend this:

1Ds Mark (no I, II or III)


Yeah I also think it´s good choice. Image quality (especially with high iso) isn´t that good as with modern FF cameras, but still superb for really big prints. Price is avesome for that kind of camera; but be aware to buy some well used, not a press workhorse.


Reply

hi there, got the same problem at the moment. I don't know witch body i got to choose. I relay like the video function and the ff sensor from the 5d mk II. But a very good AF system and a good "pictures per second" performance gives me a lot of benefits (i use about 50% fast AF lenses for Sport). But i didn´t found many information about the 1d mk III and manual lenses... px and weight don't count for me.

is the 1d mk III a (very) good camera for m42 & c/y?

btw the 1ds XX is no choice for me.

thx for your help
bye Pascal

p.n. sry for my bad english, just work at it


Reply

I get same trouble, 5D or 1D MIIn , now I think buy new 7D and old 5D use for backup Wink
Mpx is not important (may be need for macro) , what we need is image quality, speed for momment, some new technologies (may be not useful if use MF lense)


Reply

Beware, once you go full frame digital, you'll never go back! Laughing


Reply

i think i can handle the risk Wink


Reply

1D is almost 16 cm tall and 5D under 12. If you plan to go get some pictures of aunt Sylvi's 80th birthday or alternatively a Hippie festival you really get attention with the 1D. "So you have this BIG camera." Smile


Reply

kansalliskala 氏の書き込み:
"So you have this BIG camera." :)


“…you bourgeois pig!” ? =)


Reply

Compare cameras at http://www.dxomark.com/

For me sensor quality is the most important issue regardless of format.

Then just look for a camera with basic features that uses that sensor. I don't care about "features" such as Live View and HD/Video recording; I just want a basic camera. The 5D first version is a stellar example; what I have. I think cost HD Video and Live View features prevent 5DII from being priced at $1500US.


Reply

Kabraxis 氏の書き込み:
hi there, got the same problem at the moment. I don't know witch body i got to choose. I relay like the video function and the ff sensor from the 5d mk II. But a very good AF system and a good "pictures per second" performance gives me a lot of benefits (i use about 50% fast AF lenses for Sport). But i didn´t found many information about the 1d mk III and manual lenses... px and weight don't count for me.

is the 1d mk III a (very) good camera for m42 & c/y?

btw the 1ds XX is no choice for me.

thx for your help
bye Pascal

p.n. sry for my bad english, just work at it


Hi Pascal.

the 1DMkIII is a great cam - but you can get problems with the AF. Many users have a lot of unsharp images and this is due to the a) firmware and/or b) the AF modul inside the cam. The different foren are full of this topic. If you will use the cam for sport I would wait for the announced 1DMkIV which will be available within the next weeks with an improved AF system. You can use this cam for your MF lenses too because the APS-H sensor has only a crop factor of 1.3.

For MF alone you can also use not such a quick cam and here I would prefer a FF cam like the 5DMKII or other.


Reply

yes, the 5dmkII would be a good choice too, but i don't like the trouble with the mirror and some mflenses. Another point for me is the perfect sealing form the 1d MK III.
The AF-problems you are talking about are fixed in the newer versions right?

greeting pascal


Reply

Kabraxis 氏の書き込み:
yes, the 5dmkII would be a good choice too, but i don't like the trouble with the mirror and some mflenses. Another point for me is the perfect sealing form the 1d MK III.
The AF-problems you are talking about are fixed in the newer versions right?

greeting pascal


I own round about 150 MF lenses. It´s not necessary to shave the mirror at the 5DMkII (maybe with the old 5D) and really - before I would begin to shave the mirror I would sell the problematic lens.

The sealing of a Serie 1 cam is always better than the sealing of a 5D or XXD or XXXD.

Whether the AF problems are now fixed? I don´t know because the new cam is not on the market at present. But I know one point very clear - I wouldn´t buy at this moment an "old" 1DMKIII body.

If I were you I would wait let say 3-4 month to see what will happen. It´s always dangerous to buy brand new stuff. Look at the actual problems with the 7D (ghost pictures). The beta testers are always the first buyers.

Wink


Reply

引用:
I own round about 150 MF lenses. It´s not necessary to shave the mirror at the 5DMkII (maybe with the old 5D) and really - before I would begin to shave the mirror I would sell the problematic lens......

....Whether the AF problems are now fixed? I don´t know because the new cam is not on the market at present. But I know one point very clear - I wouldn´t buy at this moment an "old" 1DMKIII body.

If I were you I would wait let say 3-4 month to see what will happen....


thx for the information, do you know if there are big differences about the
viewfinder of the 5dxx and the 1dxx series?


Reply

The viewfinder of the 1D is brighter and has 100 %. But thats marginal. Furthermore you have more different focusing screens for the 1D...


Reply

i couldn't resist, last week i bought a used 1d MK III. This Cam is so amazing. The Bright Viewfinder in combination with the Canon split focus screens is perfect for my needs.

-now i got, a good ISO-range
-fast AF System for my newer lenses
-very bright and big viewfinder with split focus
-a weather resistant body
-the ability to save the hole custom functions to a file (and reload) for fast switching the complete Cam settings from MF to AF lenses

and much more....

btw: on the way to my hometown (where the cam was shipped to). I have found a Kiron 105mm 2.8 MC 1:1 in a photo dealer where i never was before. For only 30Euro (45 Dollar) this lens moved quickly to my backpack.

so have a nice day
bye Pascal


Reply

Congrats !

And good luck with the AF system. Wink


Reply

Kabraxis 氏の書き込み:
i couldn't resist, last week i bought a used 1d MK III. This Cam is so amazing. The Bright Viewfinder in combination with the Canon split focus screens is perfect for my needs.

-now i got, a good ISO-range
-fast AF System for my newer lenses
-very bright and big viewfinder with split focus
-a weather resistant body
-the ability to save the hole custom functions to a file (and reload) for fast switching the complete Cam settings from MF to AF lenses

and much more....

btw: on the way to my hometown (where the cam was shipped to). I have found a Kiron 105mm 2.8 MC 1:1 in a photo dealer where i never was before. For only 30Euro (45 Dollar) this lens moved quickly to my backpack.

so have a nice day
bye Pascal


congrats tp your camera but reading this

Kabraxis 氏の書き込み:
I have found a Kiron 105mm 2.8 MC 1:1 in a photo dealer where i never was before. For only 30Euro (45 Dollar) this lens moved quickly to my backpack.


... is Shocked Shocked Shocked a shock!! This is one amazing lens and usually goes for 200 EURos!!

tf


Reply

Shocked <-- this was nearly my reaktion to the shop owners answer:
"how much do you must have for this old lense"

I thought it would be 100-200Euro..